Hey Monday Beneath It All
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
bloc
August 23rd 2010


70120 Comments


I'll check this out, I liked the lead single.

heyadam
August 24th 2010


4395 Comments


Why did I get three ghost negs? I mean one's probably from sea, am I right? but it wasn't a bad written review

mvdu
August 24th 2010


992 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

Hmm, maybe sea did neg since I neg'd his review (wish I could take it back as it's not THAT bad.) I liked your review, heyadam, because short and to the point reviews are my fave.

heyadam
August 24th 2010


4395 Comments


lol it's cool, sputnik isn't my life. I just felt this deserved more than a 2, so I did my own.

SeaAnemone
August 24th 2010


21429 Comments


I neg'd. your analyzation is very very threadbare. it's awesome that you're taking a different p.o.v., seriously, but you're gonna need to explain yourself a little better, provide an argument rather than simply saying, "this happens. it's good." your 4th paragraph a perfect example of this.

on top of that, your review is written like so... "but it wasn't a bad written review", either grammatically incorrect or just plain awkward-sounding.

BallsToTheWall
August 24th 2010


51228 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

I Dont wanna dance has been my anthem and I dont think it will let up.

heyadam
August 24th 2010


4395 Comments


Alright man, i'll do better, but I don't see THAT many grammatical errors and its not that awkward either. I can see why you neg'd it though I guess.

SeaAnemone
August 24th 2010


21429 Comments


thanks for changing your mind. I'm assuming that's why 2 other people neg'd too.

heyadam
August 24th 2010


4395 Comments


3 now, but I'm also still trying to better my writing. It just seems like this is less of a judging of writing, than it is a major difference of opinions. Cause I have seen far worse written reviews that have done well because it agrees with the general population's view of the material

SeaAnemone
August 24th 2010


21429 Comments


Me: 2 other

+ Me = 3. and yes, I agree, when you take a more controversial stance, obviously, you're going to be open to more scrutiny, you have to justify yourself better. you didn't here. for instance, I feel that one of my personal best-written reviews is one of my fewer ones that has a bunch of negs, simply because it goes way against popular opinion. on the other hand, if the writing is adequate, 9 times out of 10 you're going to get almost all pos' I've noticed.

like I said, here, there's no strong argument. you flat-out ignored the biggest complaints on the album (for me, at least) the lyrics and production, and instead just ambiguously grazed over the rest, said "this happens then this happens" and then later said "it's good," but never really analyzed or argued, which is really what constitutes good writing, I think, in a [important part!] review.

hope this helps

bloc
August 24th 2010


70120 Comments


I Don't Wanna Dance was the one song that got me hyped for this, but the rest of the songs were just average.

heyadam
August 24th 2010


4395 Comments


Alright man thanks a lot for your input. I'll definitely put that into consideration next time I do a review. And I'll edit up this one some time tomorrow, and fix some of those issues.

therandomness
August 29th 2010


59 Comments


srsly your recommended tracks weren't the best ones. wish you were here is definitely the greatest. just saying.

heyadam
September 2nd 2010


4395 Comments


I definitely prefer Hangover to any other song on there



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy