Album Rating: 4.0

this is easily your most accessible review (ironic), and i think your most well-written honestly as it makes some salient points. i just think it ends a bit abruptly after you make your point - i would've liked a bit more analysis about how this really illustrates the "death throes" of indie music and what not.

review's unarguably well-written but you have some weird ideas (also dated) about electronic music; also faulting this album because it doesn't meet those prerequisites is kind of silly. also wish you would've expanded this review out further, it just kind of like ends right when it seems you have the opportunity to say a lot of interesting stuff and back up your claims

plus, if your posts in various threads are to be believed, you just heard this yesterday? i mean, c'mon man, you gotta give albums like these a bit more of a chance than you are

Album Rating: 3.5

well this isnt surprising or anything. I just tend to think that most people who don't like this album go in expecting something it's not trying to be, then fault MPP for not reaching that standard



To be fair, I had no expectations at all. Anyway, the review is well written and I agree with the rating.

Album Rating: 5.0

he was like 'i might listen to this' and we were like 'review it!!!!' i mean it's not really his fault but w/e

holy shit its michael jackson

Album Rating: 5.0

whats with the influx of mediocre ratings for this album



seems like only recently people started giving this ratings in the 1, 2 range

Album Rating: 2.0

Strong review, although I liked your CTTS one the best.

Album Rating: 2.5

this album definitely doesn't deserve a 1 or 1.5, regardless of personal preference. I think even someone who doesn't like it can appreciate the quality of the music. I mean, I don't particularly like it nor do I listen to it very often (with the exception of like 2-3 songs), but even I can admit it's deserving of no less than a 2.5

Album Rating: 2.0

I've hated this shit from Day 1, this is just the first I'm coming to bitch about it.

Album Rating: 2.0

It would be a 1.5 or a 2 without My Girls.

Thank you for doing this review.

but but but Summertime Clothes...

Album Rating: 2.5

My Girls and Summertime Clothes do save this from a 2-2.5 for me too. But, they're here, therefore it gets a 3.

Very nice MJ, finally a review that sees the light.

Dude, when I saw this in the approval queue and noticed your name attached to it, I literally said out loud - "Fuck. Again?" (quietly cause I'm at work). Nice review, though. It's easy for most readers to tell the difference between someone expressing their opinion and someone that seems more concerned with inflammatory statements and pissing everyone off.

Album Rating: 4.5

i disagree with your overall position on the album, but i think your review is intelligent and well written.

Impressive. Not since thebhoy's 3-score rating for Sigur Ros' Untitled have I seen a controversial review as positively accepted (so far, anyway) as this.

mj delivers...album does not

just envisioned michael jordan delivering pizza this is the best vision ever

"Here's your pie - what's your opinion on Animal Collective?"