Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

lol, I'm not an elite at all. and no, leave the Chapter I: parts, that's how the actual track list is.

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

yea, but that's the track listing.



and they ruined the demos.

i never heard the demos so idk

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

well you really should. they're leagues ahead of this

Album Rating: 4.0

The demos are a lot more raw and agressive from what I'm hearing...I'm only on the first track though and while it isn't necessarily on par with the original Part I it's still a darn good song and I don't think the production has ruined it (yet)This Message Edited On 11.30.08

well you really should. they're leagues ahead of this

Have you heard of the Q-Tip?

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

no i have not heard of the q-tip

Album Rating: 3.5

Part I/Chapter I is definitely taken down a notch, but I'll admit the rest of the album is great with Chapter IV and V sounding a whole lot better.

Album Rating: 4.0

If IV actually sounds BETTER then that will automatically make the album awesome...

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

it doesn't, it sounds worse.

Album Rating: 4.0

Well I will decide that for myself mister Caruso thank you very much...

you sure bout that

i might give this a full listen.This Message Edited On 11.30.08

i have been a long time tfot fan and i have been waiting for this for years now...i had to listen to it a few times to fully understand what they had done...overall i think its good...far better than manipulator....except that they took the keys out of part II!!!!!!!!!!! and they f-in xylophone or what ever they have going on at random times PISSES ME OFF...but over all its good

Album Rating: 4.0

what the holy hell have they done to part 1 =/



In fact, no, Chapter 1's still passable, but the vocals on chapter four suckThis Message Edited On 12.01.08

Album Rating: 3.0

I had submitted it before. Along with artwork and a tracklist, before this review was posted. It's showing up now. And I had apparently actually reviewed it as a 3/5. Which I'm glad of. Every day that goes by has me a little more disappointed. I expected Erak to put his ego aside, but he totally did not. it almost feels like radio rock sometimes. and pure stupid at other times. it hurts. it .. it hurts bad.

Album Rating: 4.5

Did anybody notice Part 6 is no where to be found?

Semi Ficition is Part 7 so i think they maybe holding 6 for there next album. But its just a thought

Album Rating: 3.5

This was a good album with a couple of superb moments per song.



Say album is 40 min long.. it was like 30 minutes 3-3.5 and 10 min 4-4.5 , but all mixed together.This Message Edited On 12.01.08

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

I think a lot of people have too much nostalgia up their ass.

At first, I didn't care for this EP so much, but after awhile I realized that it really is much better than the ghostship EP



Listen to it a couple of times before you say it sucks.

Album Rating: 4.0

same. I was thinking at first "oh this sucks" and so on. but it's actually a solid album. yes, the production is woeful, and yes, the transitions hinder rather than help, and yes, the clean vocals aren't great, but they're minor things. it's still a 4

Album Rating: 4.5

I've been listening to this album non-stop all day. It's grown on me, the chill intermissions, Thomas' vocals not being EXACTLY THE SAME AS GHOSTSHIP (for all of you that can't seem to get over the past) and Frank's contributions to the remade tracks, renew them as my favorite band of all time. Thom's vocals never sucked in the first place, i don't know any faithful fan that ever disliked them, it's usually the thing that draws them in in the first place, and Manipulator showed versatility from the same ol' same ol' raw sound they'd been producing for four years. Phantom is definately a cut above the rest and the production isn't even bad, i don't know if we're listening to the same thing but damn, it's finally here, don't be so picky. and to the pricks that are rating this album on their first listen: NEVER RATE AN ALBUM AFTER OR DURING YOUR FIRST LISTEN.