Terrible. Fantano was correct

Album Rating: 3.0

There are times when critics are right

Album Rating: 4.1

There are also times when critics aren't right

Terrible. Fandango was correct

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

There are also times when critics aren't right [2]

If Fantano thinks this is a 1 I have to 5 it now

But if venin thinks it’s a 5 I need to keep it 1’d

This is quite the conundrum

Album Rating: 5.0

there ya go

Album Rating: 5.0

Split the difference, 2.5

Album Rating: 4.1

All hail the melon lord

I would split the difference for a 2.5 but it would be irresponsible to reward birdbrains ongoing preemie meltdown

“remember there being a decisive (but not outright disrespectful) skew towards Neurosis way back hold up

https://www.sputnikmusic.com/list.php?memberid=538903&listid=94664

Neurosis fandom really fell off here even before the Scott Kelly stuff came out”

Oh wow I actually just realized that you can now safely say isis is the GOAT post metal band and grumpy neurosis simps can’t say shit lmao

isis is alright. i used to not like neurosis that much but ive come around to them a decent bit. dont really like post metal as a whole

Isis has the best discog of the post metal big three it’s not even a question. Not a single album short of great. Neurosis has several mid albums, so does cult of lulu

Album Rating: 3.0

"Absence makes the heart grow fonder, unless it's ItAoT. Thankfully WR exists."



That album is their worst but it's still great. Agreed they're better than CoL and Neurosis but I'm not that big on Neurosis to begin with.

Album Rating: 3.0

Also I think fantano gave this a "not good" fyi

Album Rating: 3.0

There are times when critics are right and wrong

Itaot is fantastic. Deffs not my least fav. Garden of light alone makes it unworthy of such a slight. But that’s the album that got me into them so I have a bias

Album Rating: 4.5

Imagine genuinely taking Fantano's opinion into account in 2023 lmao

Imagine taking his opinion into account in any year