Album Rating: 4.5

OG still got a chokehold on me, the more youthful vocals lend themselves better to most of these songs. Very good rendition regardless

Album Rating: 4.5

I prefer older Dustin’s vocal tone personally, so I guess I’m biased to the re-recording.

Album Rating: 2.0

blows dick

Album Rating: 4.0

sounds like you think this blows dick

Album Rating: 4.0

I inexplicably just realized this exists. Between that and the announcement of Horizons/West - it's Thrice season babes. Man they fucking rule

Silhouette and Paper Tigers sound great on here.
Unlike the first three track in particular.

Also agree with whomever mentioned that the drums have lost some punch.

The T/T and Stare at the sun remain just as skippable as before, even minus the whiny vocals (-:

Album Rating: 4.0

"The T/T and Stare at the sun remain just as skippable as before, even minus the whiny vocals (-:"



u dum?

Album Rating: 4.5

Paper Tigers and Abolition of Man are wayy stronger here. Silhouette is definitely weaker, but that track is all about the ferocious energy.

Album Rating: 3.0

The rerecording feels so pointless. The only thing on it that was superior to the OG was Stare at the Sun imo

Album Rating: 4.0

I never was kicking and screaming for this to be re-worked because it didn't need it but I am so glad they did. For a shuffle's sake, the make-up of these tracks and recording and granular nature fits so much better with contemporary Thrice (a la tracks live all can co-exist in a similar aesthetical space). So many of the choices outside of recording quality etc are subtle but I love some of the more melodic decision making done on moments here throughout too.

Album Rating: 4.0

This was cool for a single listen then never again.

Album Rating: 4.0

Paper Tigers and Stare at the Sun are the highlights. I still think the original Paper slightly trumps this one, but I prefer this Stare at the Sun.



The Abolition of Man and The Melting Point of Wax are really good too.



Silhouette is meh, far cry from the original. T/t is a travesty. Sounds tired as fuck. T/t on the original is 2nd best track on it.

Album Rating: 4.5

Honestly, I could listen to either version of this album depending on which I'm preferring at the time and I'm happy. Both are really solid.

Album Rating: 4.0

Just listened again and yeah, I’m bumping this up to a 4. Both are 4s for me.



I think you’re spot-on with your assessment there. Kinda cool to have both. And the fact that both feel like they serve a certain mood and purpose, is proof positive that it wasn’t a pointless endeavor.



I definitely prefer Dustin’s raspier vocals, though there are some tracks where they don’t fit the vibe/energy of the song — particularly the t/t, but also Silhouette imo.