i actually think this is a little overrated and too much focus is put on it especially in comparison to roman candle, which is better.

however, christian brothers, as well as the twofer that ends the album, is some of his best work.

Album Rating: 4.0

^ agreed. i'd take either/or and roman candle over this

eh, I've always thought that either/or and roman candle have their distinctive flaws which are sorta endearing but also bring down the albums a little.


but then again it's elliott smith no point in ranking all awesome right

true

i just remember, and i'll need to give more listens to confirm this, not being ENTHRALLED with

"5. Single File
6. Coming Up Roses
7. Satellite
8. Alphabet Town
9. St Ides Heaven"

this whole section

album still is great though

Album Rating: 4.5

lol wtf

puked of how good it was right chan?

it's an awful awful troll... who weirdly enough is 100% devoted to imitating/making fun of me or something. I'm like almost sure I know who it is but it's still a little weird.

Album Rating: 4.5

Either/Or seems to drag in a couple places compared to this and XO, imo.

This is a brilliant album but I find it difficult to connect with on a personal level. I've only managed that with Either/Or.

Album is great upon first listen, improving after subsequent ones.

""5. Single File
6. Coming Up Roses
7. Satellite
8. Alphabet Town
9. St Ides Heaven""

Honestly, Satelitte is one of the best here, and Alphabet Town and St. Ides Heaven are really strong as well.

In my opinion, of course

Album Rating: 4.5

Christian Brothers and Needle in the Hay are my favorites

Needle In The Hay's chord progression caught me off guard, I'm not entirely sure what to think of it.

Album Rating: 4.5

You were supposed to jizz

That I certainly didn't do.

Album Rating: 4.5

Either/Or feels more consistent to me, but this has my favorite tracks.

Elliott Smith

Elliott Smith

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

destroys Either/Or

Album Rating: 4.0

no it doesnt cause Either/Or has Angeles