Amy Winehouse Back to Black
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
AtavanHalen
July 24th 2011


17919 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

No, fuck that "to each his own" bullshit - if you honest-to-God believe that she had no talent then there is no expressing how dumb you are

YouGotLucky
July 24th 2011


971 Comments


^ that

AtavanHalen
July 24th 2011


17919 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Really sorry to hear that Phaze

AtavanHalen
July 24th 2011


17919 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Oh god, you don't have family in Norway too, do you? That would be awful.



So terrible what's happened over there - this weekend has sucked.

anarchistfish
July 24th 2011


30562 Comments


"my family's comparing it to Winehouse's death."
wtf?

Baphomet
July 24th 2011


7363 Comments


Dude, you can say you don't enjoy her music, that's being entitled to an opinion.

Saying she HAS NO TALENT counts more as a statement as an opinion; if you are not aware of her musical talent (despite you not liking her) you either don't want to realize or you are musically impaired. I'm hoping it's the former.

Here's an example for you: Hitler was a genius, that's not up for debate. However you can have different opinions on whether what he did with that genious was good for you or not.

robertsona
Emeritus
July 24th 2011


28661 Comments


this album is really good. i think the overriding aesthetic is a little much for me but most of the
songs are awesome. it's too bad her death has been overrun by the same "why do you guys care about a
famous person but not [insert more "innocent" deaths]!!!!" elitism. really dumb shit happens on the
internet when people die. RIP

w/r/t her "talent": saying she has no talent is pretty much insane, although i'm also bewildered how
you could personally not enjoy a lot of the songs here, like "rehab". i thought everyone liked
that song, haha. i posted a video a while back in this thread before she died that imo really proves
her talent

Enotron
July 24th 2011


7695 Comments


although i don't agree with atavan's general demeanor, i agree that saying she has "no talent" is a dumb statement. it's pretty clear she knows how to sing, it doesn't matter whether you like her songs or not.

just because something is technically your opinion doesn't mean it can't be a really misinformed opinion.

porch
July 24th 2011


8455 Comments


Here's an example for you: Hitler was a genius, that's not up for debate.


terrible example, that's definitely up for debate

Crymsonblaze
July 24th 2011


8232 Comments


I don't enjoy any of her music in the slightest but saying she was talentless is simply wrong.

Baphomet
July 24th 2011


7363 Comments


terrible example, that's definitely up for debate

take it to my shoutbox then, I really would like to debate that.

On what ground do you call her untalented? I mean, it's pretty obvious she can hit notes most people can't. That to me is talent.

Enotron
July 24th 2011


7695 Comments


it can be your "opinion" that the earth is flat or that millions have died from marijuana, but you would still be wrong. now obviously the concept of "talent" is less factual than the previously mentioned, but you still lose a certain amount of credibility when you call her talentless

Leviathan8937
July 24th 2011


264 Comments


Is good but I prefer Frank

Crymsonblaze
July 24th 2011


8232 Comments


"To me, range > natural talent."

That's stupid.

Enotron
July 24th 2011


7695 Comments


however you don't see any talent in having a good voice

Pharoh
July 24th 2011


3325 Comments


Hitler was a genius,


uhhh yeah a genius takes cyanide and quits life.

Enotron
July 24th 2011


7695 Comments


^dumbest logic

since when does being suicidal equate to being dumb?

Pharoh
July 24th 2011


3325 Comments


By not owning up like a genius. He should have thought of something.

Sciroccu
July 24th 2011


985 Comments


I wasn't fond of her music but it's sad.

AtavanHalen
July 24th 2011


17919 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

It's always great when someone dies and all of you degenerate fucks come out of your little holes to infect all around you with your mindlessness



Eat shit and die, fucking zitface trolls



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy