Best pumpkins tune ever.

Album Rating: 5.0

As soon as the sun comes out and the thrrup thrrup thrrup opening of cherub rock kicks in no other album matters.

Hard to disagree, the last 2 minutes of Hummer is one the best things ever.

Album Rating: 4.5

This has the best production of any album I've heard.

Album Rating: 5.0

I love everything on this album (except the occasional times where I bitch about Luna) but I still have to go with Geek USA for favorite.

Haven't listened to this in ages (read: months). Could do a lot worse!!

Album Rating: 5.0

One of two incredible albums that Billy makes his name off of.

Album Rating: 5.0

Gish and Adore rule too though

^Adore is great

"I love everything on this album (except the occasional times where I bitch about Luna)"

It's a perfect closer Ars, if anything spaceboy would probably be the weakest link. Adore is great [2] , hard to not love 'To Sheila' and 'Shame', to name a couple.

Album Rating: 5.0

Spaceboy is one of the biggest highlights, are you kidding?



The mellotron, the lyrics about his autistic brother... the pick up, dude it's top 3 in my opinion.



I'd prefer the album would go out in a bang, Mayonaise should have been the closer or Silverfuck haha

Eh i just don't really care for it. Nice to see love for Silverfuck though ahah, underrated tune.

Album Rating: 5.0

Spaceboy is one of the biggest highlights [2], I would argue that "Sweet Sweet" is the weakest link. It's pretty blatant filler, but it serves its purpose because a.) it sounds pleasant enough and b.) it works well as a buffer between the manic "Silverfuck" and the dreamlike "Luna"

Album Rating: 5.0

I love Sweet Sweet too, honestly Luna's my only weak link but it's still pretty good

Mayonnaise would make a great closer with it being plucked from it's original position and just moved to to end but I'm used to Luna as the closer so I have no complaints

Album Rating: 5.0

Call me crazy Ars... but I would argue that "Luna" is a highlight and "Silverfuck" is a relative low point (it's still a great tune and the bookends go hard, but the midsection drags a bit)



"Luna" is a perfect closer imo, it's stunningly beautiful and feels like the calm after the storm that is the rest of the album

Album Rating: 5.0

Oh wait you're just talking about the song Silverfuck alone... I like the midsection

Album Rating: 5.0

I meant the midsection of "Silverfuck" not the album, "Geek USA" and "Mayonaise" are my Top 2 as well :P

Album Rating: 5.0

I realized that whoops, but yeah honestly I don't mind a single second on this entire album except for Luna just because I feel like it'd make more sense in the middle of the album.

Silverfuck - Sweet Sweet - Luna is actually a perfect sequence for me and i wouldn't touch it one bit. At least we all agree this is a hard 5 :]