Album Rating: 3.5

also



"wait people don't like Reckoning?

that's wild to me, easily top 3 here"



v unsurprised to find that this track belongs to the bottom tier

Album Rating: 4.0

I get seeing it that way



but all odes to Caleb rise high

Album Rating: 3.5

fair dos



not sure what to rate this for now, but the artwork is fab so I guess I'll 5 it up to the BNM board and we'll figure the rest out later

Album Rating: 4.0

I got a b/w poster with the extended art and it looks gorgey

Album Rating: 4.0



I gotta admit, I'm also enjoying this more than Jupiter'



stop this

Album Rating: 4.0

Is that an honnest 5 jhony? If so I m proud of you :*



Edit: wait...I read the actual text

Album Rating: 3.5

yeah the emotional content of Reckoning makes it hit a lot harder than Brodsky's very cornball lyrics on the rest of the album lol. my interest in johnny takes on this is subzero btw do not contact me on this line again

Album Rating: 4.0

is he still being edgy idk i’m not on here as much now

Album Rating: 3.5

stop protesting too hard you're not as good at it as you used to be get back to blurting bad takes sans defensive reflexes plz. keep that staff badge polished

Album Rating: 3.5

nothing has changed. rowan is just pretending to have less patience for being held accountable for his atrocities

Album Rating: 4.0

what else is new with the two of you lol

Album Rating: 3.5

goodness knows haha, but I think I like this band more than I did before, so that's something

Album Rating: 3.5

man johnny this ain't the thread. just chill for fucking once

why dont we all hold hands and smile

Album Rating: 4.0

Just finished my first listen, a longggg album but damn was this tasty. The last two songs were just killer.

Album Rating: 3.5

"man johnny this ain't the thread. just chill for fucking once"

excuse me, but as someone who came to this thread with good faith, enthusiasm and ultimately respect for this album, I do not appreciate being told to chill by someone whose purchase on this page is drenched in hyperdefensive passagg. i get that your schtick is still taking a St Sebastian pose and bemoaning site Discourse, but can you please not act like you're part of the problem (if you even want to call it that in this context) here?

in other news, Searchers of Hell do be slapping

Album Rating: 4.0

johnny baring fangs aight that’s a change

yeah tbh johnny seemed pretty tame and jokey row i do think you might have overreacted

but lets all kiss and rub eachothers shoulders

I have to google who st Sebastian is brb

Album Rating: 3.5

I feel left out on this entire page, can you bros just kiss and chill?