Album Rating: 1.5
its funny either way
|
| |
agreed
|
| |
aoty? probs
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.8
saddest thing about this is that there's a pretty clear path to a solid album if they cut half of this
There's a fair amount of good ideas and songs here that get buried in the redundancy
|
| |
Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off
Come on Neek this is ass and you know it is
|
| |
there's a clear path to a still very shit album if you cut some tracks
|
| |
if you cut this down to the Dopamine song and the Witch song and a couple of whatever songs you'd have a forgivable EP that no-one would remember enough to hold against the band
but no
|
| |
"Come on Neek this is ass and you know it is"
I mean he 4ed both Machina albums so its entirely possible he doesn't
|
| |
The only thing Corgan has ever done that warrants anything above a 3.5 is Siamese Dream and even that's a stretch
|
| |
^thank you
|
| |
Album Rating: 1.5
Adore?
|
| |
Adore isn't terrible but it shitsure ain't a 4+
|
| |
Yeah, Adore is more inoffensively mediocre than outright bad, and ig that's something to be grateful for
|
| |
Album Rating: 1.5
"The only thing Corgan has ever done that warrants anything above a 3.5 is Siamese Dream and even that's a stretch"
I hate Corgan as much as any Pumpkins fan but this is an atrocious take
|
| |
Well if you're a pumpkins fan then it would be pretty unreasonable to expect you to agree with me on that
|
| |
Also let's be real the only actually controversial implication there is that Mellon Collie is a 3.5 or lower
|
| |
accurate. MC is a rough album to rate because it's like a Russian doll with a 4 inside a 3 inside a 2
|
| |
haha
|
| |
Album Rating: 1.5
well not necessarily controversial but you're still wrong (Siamese Dream is a near-5 and Gish is at least 4, Adore is great too)
tho I would say it's pretty controversial to pretend that rating Siamese Dream over a 3.5 is somehow a minority take. like it's not objectively one of the most acclaimed and best-loved rock albums of all time, y'know
|
| |
I agree it would be very weird to act like rating SD highly is controversial! Good thing literally no one is doing that!
|
| |
|
|
