Album Rating: 4.5

i think fire above, ice below is the best song i've ever heard...i unno how many times i've said that itt but there ya go

Album Rating: 5.0

Sky fire above, ice below the hearth.... so gud

Fire Above is this album's grower...so good

Prob their best

Album Rating: 4.8

Nah second best.

This or the Mantle both are 4.5 to me but this one is kinda top the mantle dunno.

Album Rating: 4.8

Pale Folklore is best though.

Its my 3rd fav but we can agree that Marrow of the Spirit is their weakest its good but not consistent enough

never heard this one yet but Agalloch is kinda hard for me to listen to at times

Album Rating: 4.8

Why?

i just have to be in a certain mood for them i guess. Wish that mood would be more often lol

Album Rating: 4.8

Eh I can understand that.

yeah i still need to re-listen to The Mantle again which i plan on doing tonight. I usually get caught up listening to Atheist, Katatonia and Leprous that i forget that there's other albums and bands I still need to hear.

Album Rating: 5.0

Agalloch is better than those bands.

Album Rating: 4.0

cept Atheist

Its my 3rd fav but we can agree that Marrow of the Spirit is their weakest its good but not consistent enough

I disagree; I put Marrow on par with Pale Folklore, and this slightly above

Marrow is misunderstood imo, but it takes a while to grow

And Into the Painted Grey is probs my fave Agalloch song (either that or The Melancholy Spirit)

Album Rating: 4.5

yeah into the painted grey is one of their best

Album Rating: 4.5

lol yeah right