Album Rating: 4.0

Boy Blue, Livin Ain't Easy, and House On Fire definitely arent better than I Can't Seem to Tell.

Album Rating: 5.0

Maybe not Boy Blue, but the other two I'd say yeah. Livin Aint Easy is great

Album Rating: 4.5

Boy Blue is the only average song here

Album Rating: 4.0

i cant seem to tell is like the best song on otip wtf

Album Rating: 4.0

Boy Blue is one of my favorites on here but okay. I’ve noticed a few of my top tracks seem to be most your guys’ least favorites. Guessing it’s probably because this is my only Menzingers album so I had no expectations going in but my least favorites are Black Mass, Your Wild Years, The Bars, and Livin Ain’t Easy is my bottom track.

Album Rating: 4.5

Get Your Wild Years out of there PUNK

Album Rating: 4.0

That track would really benefit from a strong chorus

Album Rating: 4.5

that chorus is gold, get out of hereeeee

Album Rating: 4.5

and also the buildup at the end of The Bars is killer dude



I do agree on Black Mass and Livin' Ain't Easy being weak points though.

Album Rating: 5.0

"i cant seem to tell is like the best song on otip wtf"

clearly, since they never play it live and nobody ever talks about it. in NO universe is that song better than burn after writing, gates, sun hotel, obituaries, good things, etc

Album Rating: 4.0

Nah that chorus is pretty bland lol and but the entire rest of The Bars is a snooze

Album Rating: 4.5

Your Wild Years rules and that chorus is devastating, get outta here

whaaaat Black Mass is so good.
I Can't Seem to Tell is also killer

Album Rating: 4.5

Gates is best Greg song and Burn After Writing is best Tom song on OTIP easily



Title track from this is my favorite Greg song ever and House On Fire is my favorite Tom song from here



imo of course

Gates and Nice things for me

Album Rating: 4.0

First five tracks are nearly a 5/5 for me and House on Fire, Boy Blue, and t/t are 4.5s. Just wish this record could hold that quality throughout

Album Rating: 4.5

also Home Outgrown is my favorite Greg song ever, I wish he would bring back the occasional scream like he used to...

Album Rating: 5.0

@wonder so why you have this at a 4 then. sounds like it should be an easy 4.5 for you

Album Rating: 4.0

Because there’s still 5 tracks I don’t like at all

Album Rating: 5.0

wtf?!? so Lookers is a 5/5 but you don't like Your Wild Years at all? How does that make any sense? The sound and quality is so consistent throughout this whole album

Also do you really think Black Mass is not a good song? I have so many questions