wish you were here is my floyd 5 easy

Album Rating: 3.0

note: I have wywh 4.5 but it's the hardest 4.8 ever

animals is a 5 yah. all of their shit is phenomenal except anything post-final cut. wish you were here is the most overrated album ever though. title track is pretty meh. only things i really love are the bookends

most overrated album ever? bold. not even close, i don't think. its not even the most overrated pink floyd album let alone the most overrated album ever

definitely the most overrated floyd imo and regularly appears in 'best albums of all time' lists the world over

I definitely don't think it's as good as Animals but the wywh t/t is one of my favorite Floyd songs

the wall is the most overrated floyd easy album is half bullshit

Album Rating: 3.0

it is even that highly regarded?

Album Rating: 4.0

whats wrong with giving drizzey dra a 5?

it definitely is....

and the wall is amazing pls

Yes, by a lot of people

I always see people calling it the best double album ever or smthn

What's going on in here?

darkside, wywh and animals are all better than the wall by far

wywh hell no. the other two maybe

just mah 'pinion!

Album Rating: 3.0

"darkside, wywh and animals are all better than the wall by far"



pretty sure that's a majority opinion

Floyd should have never put out this album though.

Album Rating: 4.0

The Wall blows



Piper doesn't get enuff luv, nor does Ummagumma

gtfo renly

damn the pink floyd rankings have escaped from the pink floyd threads lol