Album Rating: 4.5

wow

Album Rating: 4.0

i definitely regard this as one of mastodon's top albums but thats just me. maybe just under crack the skye and leviathan

Album Rating: 3.0

not even in the same stratosphere as Crack the skye

True because this one is better.

Album Rating: 3.0

brings the zzzzzzzzz's so hard

I like this and Hunter (this slightly more), but I don't see how this style could ever beat any of the first 4

Album Rating: 3.0

I need more cavemen sailors in their music

less choruses more riffs

But not like Crack They Skye please. Thank you.

Okay man, we get it, you like this more than Crack the Skye. You can have "different" opinions without trying so damn hard to be as contrarian as possible for attention

Album Rating: 3.5

fewer choruses, more stuff that didn't bore us twice already in the song

or better choruses, at least. on Leviathan there are choruses but they're different each time. Seabeast has the refrain that gets more intense each time around, Iron Tusk has two motifs that return a couple times with different lyrics, Hearts Alive has ABAB form in the first half but then goes onto new things.

Perfect, now once more.

This is better than Crack The Skye.

[/ImmatureHour]

crack the skye rulez

Album Rating: 4.5

remission is their best work anyway.

Album Rating: 3.0

yea

I like Leviathan the most

Album Rating: 3.5

first four are interchangeable depending on my mood.

Album Rating: 3.5

fight me

12AM, at the playground tomorrow

Album Rating: 3.5

that would be tonight at midnight right

the day starts at 12AM