The Smashing Pumpkins Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


Sorry boys, (sorry boys, I dont know where to find the signs/marks or whatchamacallit... english is my second language so cut me some slack. Please! I beg of you!) Anyway, I dont want to interrup the debate, that"s going on but... let me just say (once again my friends, I apologise for my piss poor english) but... MUZZLE and TONIGHT, TONIGHT are the greatest things Billy?ve eved did (once again, I apologize for my vocabulary and my forming of senteces... I'm full of shit)

Yeah. Muzzle and Tonight, Tonight. Fuck, man, Even if I could write in english language, I couldn't describe the feelings...

Hell, man! I coulnd't describe in my mother language, what those songs mean/do to me!

Fucken legendary album/band... Ican't write in english to save my life

Mellon Collie, man. Worship, man.

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


No filler, all killer!


Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


I really do mean that, fellas. Each side is killer. Second side is fucken (I won't say underrated... though it is), but it is overlooked, underappreciated!

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


It's not so immediate (speaking of 2nd side). It doesn't hit you like the first one, but man... it's just as good. I could've talk this an that abiut 2nd side, but, man... It takes time. You have to give it time... And when time comes... Reality hits you hard, bro! Sure as shit!

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


Once again, I apologize for stinking up the tread with my neverending posts... and my piss poor english language. I mean it!

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


Fuck my english language. Mellon Collie is stuff of legends. I love it, man

YoYoMancuso
Emeritus
August 19th 2016


19776 Comments

Album Rating: 4.7

Bullet With Butterfly Wings is def in the bottom half of songs here but it's not bad

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


Honestly, I've never really cared about Bullet... Don't get me wrong... It's a killer song, especially the ending... But there's so much different stuff going on on both discs, that it kind of... I don't know... it becomes pale in comparison, so to speak.

theNateman
August 19th 2016


3809 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Well the lyrics on butterfly are kinda cringey tho tbh.

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


Perfect for a single, but it's the lesser songs; songs that remain eternailly overlooked; that don't get enough credits... That makes this album so special.... Singles and best known songs... fucken killer they are, but when you look deep down itno the entire album... and you discover... piece here and small piece there... just a small guitar part or something... and it's IT. Fuck!

theNateman
August 19th 2016


3809 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

What's with all the "..."s dude?



And I agree. The deep cuts are some of the best here. Like We only go out at night, and Ruby and stumbleine. Cupid de Locke is absolutely gorgeous

ArsMoriendi
August 19th 2016


42443 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Even though I know, I suppose I'll show, all my cool and cold-like old Job!



Biblical references heh

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


"Well the lyrics on butterfly are kinda cringey tho tbh."

I hear you, my man. Pumpkins were always slaged (is that the right word?, sorry), but, man. There's some stuff, that's (let's face face it) cringe worthy, but, man... That's life... I don't know, Siamese Dream... Always complaints from people, but my man... They aren't that bad... There's stuff that's cringey, yeah of course, but there's some stuff that hits you right in the bone (is that how you say it?)... Anyway. Pumpkins were FUCKEN GREAT. WORSHIP!


Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


"What's with all the "..."s dude? "

Sorry, my man. Just something to hide (unscuscefully though) my piss poor attempt at writing in english language.

But you are right. Stumbleine kills me every single time.

NordicMindset
August 19th 2016


25137 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I never was too crazy about Bullet, but it's not a bad song

theNateman
August 19th 2016


3809 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

@dunwich- no worries bro I was just wondering.



It's funny cuz I'd be reading your comments and I'd see the "..." And in my head I'd hear you trail off like you were zoning out in this like deadpan voice

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


Same here, my man. I kinda understand why it was a single, but it's not even close to being one of the finer cuts from the record. Same goes for Zero. Both killer songs, hats off, but there's greater stuff to be found on the record.

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


^ response to Green baron


ArsMoriendi
August 19th 2016


42443 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

If I had to rank the singles:



Tonight, Tonight > Zero > 1979 > Bullet with Butterfly Wings > Thirty-Three

Dunwich
August 19th 2016


582 Comments


Hey nateman, thanks a lot. I'd be a lot more active here, if only i could write in proper enlgish, without making a complete fool out of myself... And yeah, I'm not sure if I completely understand what have you just written (man, I'm not even sure if that sounds right, I'm trying) but yeah... I'm zoning out (don't ask).

Cheers mate, I appreciate it. I really do!



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy