Album Rating: 2.5

Hey Plat, your review got quoted on the Wikipedia page for the album under "critical reception". I was checking to see if anyone was talking shit about the album but it seems to be getting universal praise.



"Anyone else getting anxiety from the art work"



Glad I'm not the only one

Album Rating: 5.0

@Get Low - YOU SERIOUS? I gotta see this shit.

Album Rating: 5.0

dude they got my name wrong lmao

Album Rating: 2.5

that is so tragic lmao

Album Rating: 5.0

It's Wikipedia - I just went and edited it lol hoping the mods don't edit it back or ask for a source. I AM the source.

Album Rating: 2.5

Oh that's interesting, I thought Wikipedia edits had to be pre-approved before they were posted.

Album Rating: 5.0

My understanding (I could be wrong) is that edits will go through, but the moderator team is lightning fast at taking down edits that are wrong, abusive, or uncited. That's how you can see people take screenshots of Wikipedia being edited to say horribly wrong/funny things, the edit will remain until a mod undoes it.

yeah. small caveats: (a) some articles are protected because too many people vandalise them. (b) vandalisers get their ip banned

Album Rating: 4.0

Once 10 years ago I went onto the Opeth-Heritage wikipedia page for shits and edited it under the reception tab to say it was underrated and the haters were wrong and it got changed back like 2 minutes later lmao

Album Rating: 4.0

less, the cure and cigarette smoke are all unbelievable god damn

Album Rating: 2.5

I think your edit is safe, Plat.

Album Rating: 2.5

how wild is the fact there's a Robert Smith ft. (and a rather great separate song called "The Cure" lol). Nearly as befuddling as finding out members of Alvvays ft. on that Miley Cyrus album.

I certainly like this more than expected.

Album Rating: 3.5

I'm enjoying this but I'm quite surprised by the reception. Sure, it's a more mature album than its predecessors, but I find it has too many quiet ballads. GUTS had more 1989-esque upbeat fun pop tunes. This is more for the Folklore/Evermore Swifties

Album Rating: 4.0

holy shit, this IS that good. incredible sequencing. feels nice to have something so prominent be in more of the pop rock sphere (the 80's tinged stuff no less)

Album Rating: 4.0

not exactly a daring record, but I do like everything that's on here

Album Rating: 4.6

BOOM!

Album Rating: 2.5

gave this a few spins and am now experiencing diminishing returns and much that struggles to retain my interest, in amongst some admittedly good stuff - The Cure being the obvious standout. Stupid Song & Maggots are decently catchy.

I think they way she writes hooks doesn't personally lend itself to longevity, I hate to say 'throwaway' but yeah kinda. Couple that with a few snoozer ballads and there aren't a lot of meatier offerings I'd feel inclined to return to.

okay, done - that's already too many words for an OR thread

i think drop dead and stupid song might be her two best songs period. if this album has any big flaw to me its that those are tracks 1 & 2 and the album doesn't quite reach those heights again

Album Rating: 4.0

I wish there were more upbeat songs on this because I find this pretty one tone, but good god it still hit hards, as someone that lost my loved one recently to a car accident



Also how is The Cure not your highlight . It is the best song of the album

Album Rating: 3.5

wish there were more upbeat songs [2]