Album Rating: 2.5

big yikes, glad i caught them on the 10 year anniversary tour for waterfront a while back, seeing that record performed in full was quite the experience

https://noise.thehardtimes.net/2020/04/26/silversteins-shane-told-on-13-of-the-bands-best-guest-artist-spots/

Fun read

Haha, I really can't hear the Grade influence in the songs I've heard from this album

Album Rating: 2.5

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VZEoE_WZtXM



this thing is pretty fun

This band is so much better than this, but then again I think their only fantastic albums are When Broken Is Easily Fixed (my favorite), Discovering the Waterfront, and This Is How the Wind Shifts.
Outside of those three, I tend to like their stuff on a song-by-song basis. These guys were my favorite band for a couple years when I was a teenager though so I have a soft spot for them and always want them to put out a great record. Their live shows still kick ass.

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

Nowadays I only ever come back to Discovering The Waterfront and This Is How The Wind Shifts

Discovering the waterfront rules

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

gotta listen to the redux Broken tracks too fo sho

I strangely feel like Discovering the Waterfront keeps getting better with age.

Same, every time I go back and expect it to have grown off me. The opposite ends up happening.

The fact that they wrote Three Hours Back in 2005 is incredible to me. It's easily a top 5 if not top 3 song of theirs IMO. The bass line getting its shining moment in the second verse is bliss every time I hear it.
I'm listening to DtW now after listening to Shipwreck, How the Wind Shifts, I Am Alive, and A Beautiful Place to Drown this morning and DtW stands out as the best.
Shane's voice is probably my favorite on DtW and they don't write choruses like they did on their first two albums.

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

I wish i could agree



Went from a stone cold 5 for me when I was in middle/high school to a 3.5 these days. Wind Shifts is definitely my favorite at this point

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

Wind Shifts numbah 1 baby

Album Rating: 2.0

run from shipwreck to wind shifts is all i really come back to now but all 3 of those albums go so hard (rescue is def their most underrated)

I think most of the choruses are too weak on Shipwreck and I don't love the production on it. My favorite song off it is the title track but according to the review thread here, nobody really likes that song. American Dream sucks though.

Album Rating: 1.5 | Sound Off

American dream is nostalgic for me because of rock band 2

I still jam it on rb4, def not my favorite song but it’s still enjoyable.

Album Rating: 3.0

bump it to 4



pretending I'm still a teenager.



"SAY Yes SAY Yes SAY Yes"

I unironically think this is the bands best work. I love this album. "Say Yes" and "Where You" hit me in the emo kid feels. I unabashedly have he musical tastes of a 14 yr old scene girl.

Album Rating: 4.0

^ Brave take.



Album is fun. Over-hated.