Album Rating: 4.0

not quite feeling your wild years yet



13. bad catholics

12. livin' ain't easy

11. house on fire

10. your wild years

9. tellin' lies

8. boy blue

7. thick as thieves

6. the bars

5. black mass

4. lookers

3. charlie's army

2. midwestern states

1. after the party

Album Rating: 4.0

Since the death of pop punk in the early 2000s

Midwestern States miiight be my fave on here
Definitely think Black Mass and T/T are the best tho

Bubs I think my ranking would be a lot like yours except I think Tellin Lies is just amazing, don't get the lukewarm reception to that one from most of y'all

Album Rating: 4.5

Midwestern States would be one of my favs but that part where he just says "THE MIDWESTERN STATES" for like 15 seconds with no chord changes or anything is really stagnant and kinda stunts the flow of the song for me



rest of it is amazing tho

That's fair but it doesn't bother me tbh and I think it's one of their absolute best choruses overall

i'm in this for the hooks so "lookers" and "charlie's army" are my favs

Album Rating: 4.0

Agreed on Midwestern States, great song except for the MIDWESTERN STATES part.

Album Rating: 4.5

wtf rented world was not super mainstream. simpler but less mainstream if mainstream = poppy

Album Rating: 4.0

agreed. this is their most straightforward and poppy album.

Album Rating: 4.5

Relieved that I love this so much. Couldn't get into rw.

Album Rating: 3.5

t/t is a jam and a half

Album Rating: 4.0

took a few listens but Tom's other 3 songs grew on me (i liked The Bars right away).

Album Rating: 4.5

t/t probably the best but lookers also divine

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Love the shout out to the Stone Pony in Your Wild Years

Album Rating: 4.0

so proud they're from my hometown

Album Rating: 4.5

best thing to come outta scranton since dunder-mifflin

Album Rating: 4.7

Captain, We're Sinking and Spraynard

Album Rating: 4.5

spraynard are from philly

Album Rating: 4.7

closeenough