this band was great until fat teenage girls started posting their lyrics all over tumblr

Album Rating: 3.5

[2]

Surprised that this is still on #1 on the frontpage.
Is it really that good?

it's better than all but one of the other albums

So I like SATB.... but couldn't really stand Wildlife. Will I like this?

And when I say like, what I really mean is absolute love it!

Album Rating: 3.5

Man, I actually dug this :/

Album Rating: 3.0

e/

It's a good record once you get into it. Not as good as some will have you believe, but better than some make it out to be

Album Rating: 3.5

like this a lot now

ye it's really not that bad it's also not very interesting to me though rip

Album Rating: 3.5

Morning after snowstorm,

how do get into this?

Album Rating: 3.5

For Mayor in Splitsville has grown on me so much. Something about that guitar in the beginning

is it the bangin' girl from coyote ugly in the video because that did it for me

who's banging

Hudsonville, Scenes From Highways, and The Child We Lost = best tracks.

video is ugh girl is ok

splitsville is one of the best on here. never quite got the hate for it when it was released

most of it was for the vocals but i think that's what makes it. it's the first time i've ever heard him sound smug

you can't deny that when he first comes in and kinda tonelessly drawls "funny what you think of" after
the sick guitar that you didn't cringe a little.

i like dreyer, but he does shit all over tracks occasionally.