Album Rating: 4.5

Well, I think I'm used to so many crappy singers that I wasn't really annoyed by Corgan's voice.



I just love this album...I kind of wish it was remastered...the "wall of noise" can be overbearing at times, and I think a more modern, clean production could do wonders...of course, some would argue that it would take away the "edge" from the album.



But this is definitely SP's strongest set of material on an album...Mellon Collie has its moments, but it's bloated and about half the album is just plain weak...needless to say, if it was released on one disc, it would be better for it (though it probably wouldn't "flow" too well...).



For some reason, I still think Billy has it in him to write another great album...I know his material has gotten weaker and weaker over time...but I can't imagine him making another album as bland and stale as Zeitgeist again...and I hope he can quit it with the sophomoric poetry...you're not in high school anymore, Billy.

Album Rating: 5.0

This album is just legendary

My favourite by the pumpkins

Album Rating: 3.5

album's good but idk it's inconsistent; there's too many slow tracks close to each other, especially towards the end. some really good songs here tho.This Message Edited On 08.09.08

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah nowheres near as good as Mellon Collie or even as good as Machina but it does have pretty much all amazing songs on here.

This IS the Pumpkin's best album. It's not inconsistent, its all blended together very well.

Album Rating: 4.0

this is a really good review. the only probably i had was when you would say " throw one off" or " surprise one". I do that a lot. it's a bad habit, but maybe it's just me.

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah, pablo honey is good Siamese dream is on a whole other level. I always thought it was crazy how Today, Disarm, and Cherub Rock sound totally different than the other songs. Mayonaise might be my favorite sp song of all time.

Album Rating: 4.5

Mellon Collie is my favorite album.. but this is fantastic too

Album Rating: 5.0

Album is epic, particularly Today, Disarm, Mayonnaise, and Geek U.S.A.

Those girls on the cover are adorable, also and not i'm not saying that in a creepy pedo way or anything, just so cute

Album Rating: 5.0

I fucking love this album

It's good.

Album Rating: 5.0

123. I just wish I was a bit older when i saw these guys live.

Album Rating: 5.0

Mellon Collie is better and more listenable in my opinion.

Album Rating: 5.0

Mellon Collie is very VERY inconsistent

Mellon Collie is very VERY inconsistent, and the tracks don't have anywhere near the coherency as on Siamese Dream. The songs here have more of a similar feel to it,(without being repetitive) while also having unique feels to each song. Mellon Collie kinda mashes together "loud" songs and "quiet" songs on the two discs without any sense of together-ness, even if Mellon Collie does have some terrific songs within the 28 of them.

and still manages to rule

Album Rating: 5.0

Great review, love this album. The pumpkins at their best in my opinion. Especialy Billy with his schoolboy haircut! Classic. I would have to disagree with silverfuck being the weak point. For me that would have to be Today. Don't know why, everyone else seems to love it, but it never really did anything for me.

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

today and disarm are awesome even though they're the most different on the album. everything else on the album is straight fuzz bliss.

Album Rating: 5.0

"Pink ribbon scars that never forget.

I tried so hard to cleanse these regrets.

My angel wings were bruised and restrained.

My belly stings"

def one of the best SP albums, never known a band to convey so many different emotions, look at the diversity between gish and adore its crazy. personally the only album i dont like is zeitgeist its pap!! im lovin pisceas iscariot atm.. also machina ii is great more so than 1!

Album Rating: 5.0

Been one of my favorite albums since I was 13.