Album Rating: 4.9

wwf kinda but there's a lot more variety too

Album Rating: 4.9

Also I think the slower songs are just as strong on this but the album is sorely missing a Georgia (maybe "Chinese Satellite" works?)

Album Rating: 5.0

Finally got around to the new one, and I absolutely love the variety presented in the album! I agree with neek that it's missing something like a "Georgia," but tracks like "Savior Complex" and (possibly her best song) "I Know the End" more than make up for it

Gonna have to spin a few more times, but I could see it overtaking this one for me

Album Rating: 4.0

Gotta say it's nice to hear Phoebe songs that haven't been overplayed in my super hip ad agency office via cool indie Spotify playlists. RIP my once undying love for Scott Street

Punisher is brilliant

Album Rating: 4.9

What makes Punisher better than Strange imo is that the weaker cuts ("Garden Song", "Moon Song") are like wayyyy better than "Chelsea" or "Would You Rather"

Album Rating: 3.0

Appreciating a lot of the subtler details on it after a second listen, like the harmonies on Chinese Satellite

Album Rating: 4.9

Chinese Satellite rules yes



I think the closest thing to "I Know the End" thematically and structurally at least is "Future" by Paramore

Album Rating: 4.5

You're right, every song on punisher is better than chelsea or would you rather. And those are still good songs! Moon Song is in the top 3 of the record for me though. Maybe the new one doesn't have a Georgia but Stranger doesn't have an I Know The End ...

Album Rating: 3.0

After a third listen I’m actually liking the new one quite a bit and I’m kind of amazed by how good the lyrics are honestly

Album Rating: 4.9

I agree with you there dust, "Georgia", "Kyoto", and "I Know the End" are my favorites from her

Moon Song is growing on me!

@Cole hell yes, her lyrics are amazing

Album Rating: 3.0

Haven’t been so impressed by an album’s lyrics since Go Farther In Lightness by Gang of Youths probably

She just appeared in the cover of the Forty-Five magazine with an Iron Maiden long sleeve licking an ice cream and that's enough for me to 5 her new album.

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah, every song is lyrically brilliant.

Album Rating: 4.9

okay new plan everyone 5's Punisher

Album Rating: 3.5

'She just appeared in the cover of the Forty-Five magazine with an Iron Maiden long sleeve licking an ice cream and that's enough for me to 5 her new album.'



it was pretty hot ngl

tried to listen n get into this but couldn’t stop thinking about church of the highlands

Album Rating: 4.3

What makes Punisher better than Strange imo is that the weaker cuts ("Garden Song", "Moon Song") are like wayyyy better than "Chelsea" or "Would You Rather"

Album Rating: 4.5

Once Savior Complex clicks with me I'm 5-ing it...and that's just a matter of time.

Album Rating: 5.0

I’m down with the 5’ing Punisher plan

Album Rating: 4.9

You Missed My Heart will click with you one day and you'll regret ever dissing it like I do