Album Rating: 4.5

true but giving it a 1.5 when there is clearly fantastic musicianship and songwriting, just because you don't like flutes, or it's too "bardlike" or whatever is a cheap undeserved low blow to an album. And whatever, people can just say it's just a rating or just an opinion, but sometimes it just comes across as obnoxious

i mean

hypothetically if you hate listening to it what rating should you give

Album Rating: 4.5

don't rate it

Album Rating: 3.0

gotta boost dat objectivity doe

Dropped to a 1

"true but giving it a 1.5 when there is clearly fantastic musicianship and songwriting"


lol

Was on the fence over whether it was a 2 or a 1.5 til dungeon boy started typing

>don't rate it

why?

If you don't like something don't rate it, the metric of a truly objective rating system rofl

Lets just revamp the system, rating scale should go from 3-5, because FEELINGS

dungeonboy by your own logic how do you justify giving liturgy's ark work a 1.5

https://xkcd.com/1098/

Woopsie is this...

A double standard??

Album Rating: 3.0

the classic "y u rate/review if you no like"

Guess dungeon has to purge all those low ratings of albums that other people like damn

"dungeonboy by your own logic how do you justify giving liturgy's ark work a 1.5"

true giving it a 1.5 when there is clearly fantastic musicianship and songwriting, just because you don't like riffs, or it's too "transcendental" or whatever is a cheap undeserved low blow to an album. And whatever, people can just say it's just a rating or just an opinion, but sometimes it just comes across as obnoxious

Album Rating: 3.0

stop it, he's already dead!

Album Rating: 4.5

lol I expected that, good job, carry on

are you not gonna answer?

You have excellent foresight.