Album Rating: 5.0

the correct answer would have been "No, that's just the shape of my head. I get that a lot."

*best lead riff ever*
DARK! DARK HORSE! WILL ONE! DAY COME!
TO FREE THE LIGHT FROM ALL OF US!
ONE DAY THE DARK HORSE WILL COME!
*best lead riff ever*
*over the best breakdown ever*
DAARRRKKK HOOOORRRRSEEE RIIIIDDDEEEE TOWARD THE LIGHT
*best lead riff ever*

Album Rating: 4.5

The best two songs on here are the last two.

Cutter

This is such a good album I wish I could rate it higher.

Album Rating: 4.5

Then do it.

But Jane Doe > You Fail Me >>>>> AtF = rest of them > No Heroes

So I can't. My logic is flawless.

Edit: When I read that again it didn't make sense so let me clarify. Jane Doe is too much better than You Fail Me for me to 5 YFM, but YFM is sooo much better than this that I can't have them both at a 4.5 because the quality isn't consistent. If I rated the albums out of the context of Converge's discography this would be a 4.5 but I can't do that.

2nd best Converge album

Album Rating: 4.5

Agree with Prolapse. Then You Fail Me.

I disagree but that's okay we all know what the top three are.

Unless johnnylapse somehow thinks another one is better than YFM

:/ I'm outnumbered.

YFM is 4th best after PTES, sorry

Fuck man. But Iluv you even have You Fail Me rated at a 5 above When Forever Comes Crashing

Album Rating: 4.5

I used to think PTES was better than You Fail Me, but then YFM grew on me a lot.

Also WFCC is my least favorite.

You Fail Me is almost as good as Jane Doe imo. I mean if not for In Her Shadow being a little overlong it would be almost a 5.

Album Rating: 4.5

I actually really like In Her Shadow.

I like it too, I just wish it didn't slow down the momentum of the album so much. It's mood is really great though. But what makes Jane Doe edge it out is that it just keeps moving along.

Yeah like First/Last Light, the title track, idk the whole thing is so goood.

whats going on here

Album Rating: 2.0

this better then jane doe?