Kill 'Em All isn't as mature as the albums that came after, I agree, but that works in its favour.

Album Rating: 3.0

The main reason this album sucks is coz it was made by M e t a l lica

Album Rating: 1.5

JamieTwort: To be fair, though, i really believe this is pretty bland even when you don't take into consideration the band or its original genre. It's not like it's a great rock (/hard rock?) album.



About Kill'em All vs And Justice for All...Yeah, Kill'em All is raw. But And Justice for All lacks the aggression and passion that we can hear in Kill'Em All. Still solid (especially compared to Load, ReLoad or St Anger xD).

Album Rating: 3.0

Blackened and Dyer's Eve lack aggression? I think not, good sir.

"The main reason this album sucks is coz it was made by M e t a l lica"

lol

Album Rating: 1.5

Can't say he's wrong, though. Metallica did make the album haha.

Album Rating: 4.5

"It's not like it's a great rock (/hard rock?) album."



Off the top of my head, this is prob a top 5 "hard rock" album of the past 20 years for me. As hyperbolic as that sounds it's really not saying much of anything though since hard rock is like the worst rock genre

Album Rating: 3.5

If anything, the Black Album was Metallica's sellout album - this is not. This goes against much of what made them popular to begin with, simple song structure aside.

Wrong, this is just a continuation of what they were doing since the Black Album.

Best Metallica album from their stoner metal era.

Album Rating: 3.5

Nah, this is in no way a natural progression from that point. It's quite a radical shift, once again, ignoring the somewhat poppy song structures, which the Black Album also had.



That's all I'm saying. Don't feel like debating right now.

So I read the cover on this album is actually blood mixed with semen and reload is blood mixed with piss. Wtf Metallica.

Album Rating: 4.5

Lars is a kinky mufucker

Album Rating: 2.5

IT AIN'T MUH FAAALL



IT AIN'T MUH CAAALL



IT AIN'T MUH BIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIITCHUUUUUUUH

Album Rating: 4.5

OPEN MY EEEYYYAAAAAAAAAEESSS

Album Rating: 3.5

Yep.



I know others have said it, but the first half of this is perfect.

Album Rating: 2.5

BUT THE CASTLE CRUMBLES AND YOU'RE LEFT WITH JUST A NAME

Album Rating: 3.0

THEY'RE OFF TO FIIIIIIIIND THE HERO OF THE DAAAAAAAAAAYYYYEEEAH

Album Rating: 3.5

JUST TO HAVE THEM CLLOOOSED

LOAD rules fuck tha haters