» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Idiot_guitarist
October 18th 2004


1 Comments


I think the album rules!! Its a great album from green day. But i thought it was city of the ****ed..so why is that ***???!
By the way green day rock!

javamler petonhemmerleber
October 19th 2004


7 Comments


two words... b oo

stke22
October 19th 2004


37 Comments


This is a pretty good album. definately a change from their previous old stuff. I'll have to listen to it a couple more times before it sinks in, but definately worth picking up.

Lelant
October 19th 2004


1 Comments


The American Idiot drum riff seems to get used a lot over the album

Roddy
October 19th 2004


4 Comments


I'm very biased when it comes to Green Day. I've been listening to them since Kerplunk and they are one of my favourite bands.

This album is brilliant. Who gives a **** about the simple lyrics or basslines. It's the simple things in life that are great

Some songs on the album I didn't like at first (St Jimmy believe it or not) but now I love them. Boulevard Of Broken Dreams may sound exactly like Oasis' Wonderwall but I still like it.

Going to see them in February and looking forward to it. They are one of those bands I still havent seen in the 10 years I've listened to them (I only just saw offspring earlier this year).

There are a bunch of flaming fanboys posting lame-*** comments on this thread. If you don't have anything good to say, shut the **** up.

Great album, one of the best this year and I will be listening to it many years to come.

9/10 (taking off a point because like everything, it's not perfect because there is one song I always skip and I'm not saying which )

javamler petonhemmerleber
October 19th 2004


7 Comments


[QUOTE]There are a bunch of flaming fanboys posting lame-*** comments on this thread. If you don't have anything good to say, shut the **** up.[QUOTE]


Who the hell are you to tell me to shut the **** up. in my opinion all of the people that think this new album is good don't know anything and they need to shut up. the only greenday that is worth listening to is old greenday and this new album is disapointing. Not all review has to be good.

Sotykid4
October 19th 2004


1 Comments


I have their albuum and personally,i think its great. I especially like they way the made Jesus of Suburbia,the umm...."punk opera." The only problem with it is that its political.I don't really think that music and politics mix,and they should stay separate because it can actually hurt the band,like they loose customers that aren't from the political party their in,or somthin like that...ya no?

SubtleDagger
October 19th 2004


737 Comments


I really don't like any Green Day, this album is just worse than everything else by them. Take that, fanboys!

The_Flash!!!!
October 20th 2004


93 Comments


avamler petonhemmerleber- the hell are you to tell me to shut the **** up. in my opinion all of the people that think this new album is good don't know anything and they need to shut up. the only greenday that is worth listening to is old greenday and this new album is disapointing. Not all review has to be good.


look noob just caus u don't like the band doesn't mean they suck. it's not a fact, it's your opinion that they suck so keep it to your frickin self a-hole.

javamler petonhemmerleber
October 20th 2004


7 Comments


[QUOTE=The_Flash!!!!]look noob just caus u don't like the band doesn't mean they suck. it's not a fact, it's your opinion that they suck so keep it to your frickin self a-hole.[/QUOTE]

But i never said that it was a fact that they suck. in fact i said i like their old stuff. i just don't like this album. And just because you like the band doesn't meen that they are good. so you should also shut up if you expect me too. If not it's something called being hypocritical. :thumb: :thumb: :thumb:

The_Flash!!!!
October 20th 2004


93 Comments


whatever go flame about them some where else and get beat down by other people. and like i said before just because u don't like them doesn't mean they suck. :angry:

javamler petonhemmerleber
October 20th 2004


7 Comments


[QUOTE=The_Flash!!!!]whatever go flame about them some where else and get beat down by other people. and like i said before just because u don't like them doesn't mean they suck. :angry:[/QUOTE]

And just like I said before just because you like them doesn't mean they are good. I was never flaming about them, just stating the fact that this album is not as good as their others. :naughty:

Roddy
October 20th 2004


4 Comments


[QUOTE=javamler petonhemmerleber]

[QUOTE]There are a bunch of flaming fanboys posting lame-*** comments on this thread. If you don't have anything good to say, shut the **** up.

Who the hell are you to tell me to shut the **** up. in my opinion all of the people that think this new album is good don't know anything and they need to shut up. the only greenday that is worth listening to is old greenday and this new album is disapointing. Not all review has to be good.


Ummm...I never mentioned you or any names and everyones entitled to their opinion. But when people post 'green day sux lol' it's really annoying (unless they are joking which is usually the case).

:thumb:

javamler petonhemmerleber
October 20th 2004


7 Comments


[QUOTE=Roddy]Ummm...I never mentioned you or any names and everyones entitled to their opinion. But when people post 'green day sux lol' it's really annoying (unless they are joking which is usually the case).

:thumb:[/QUOTE]

ouch. you got me. I'll make sure I'm more careful next time I post an anger rant.

MANIX-IV
October 21st 2004


1 Comments


Not much to say...
































...great album.

MetallicShineX
October 21st 2004


1 Comments


[QUOTE=ThE_B.P.C]good review but im afraid i nearly stabbed myself when i heard this song (literaly i dropped the knife when i was cutting some bread lol)
'one nation controlled by the media?'
ok lets think who distirbutes there music? big media companies. who advertises it? big media companies. who plays their video on tv? big media companies.

isnt that slightly hypocritical[/QUOTE]

Not really, just a bit ironic. Did Green Day want it to happen? I have a good idea that they just want a widespread distribution to get their message across. If the world wasn't like that then they wouldn't have ended up doing it.

Arucard
October 21st 2004


581 Comments


i dont know
they are rolling in it, so why dont they use theyre money to campaign for someone else to be elected
or make there own tv channel or record label they can afford it

beek
October 21st 2004


1 Comments


Ok, let me put in my 2 cents worth:

If you enjoy listening to the ear-splitting noise that americans call "Green Day", then may god take your miserable life quickly. I take pity on all of the fools who think that this music is punk, or even rock. You senseless morons had better go to sleep before you hurt yourself trying to scratch the fleas out of your hair.

Anybody want to talk about this, add me on msn messenger at [email]grahamvalliant@hotmail.com[/email].

Dancin' Man
October 22nd 2004


719 Comments


[QUOTE=Iai]The VBCode & Grammar Police really need to hit this thread.[/QUOTE]

By thread I hope you mean every thread ever started on these boards.

stke22
October 22nd 2004


37 Comments


[QUOTE=guitari265]^^^ someone please explain the intent of that post[/QUOTE]

he also spammed the poppunk forum. gonna get banned soon if continued.

man... i'm listening to Chuck more than American Idiot now, lol!



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy