Album Rating: 2.0

no....

Album Rating: 4.0

strangers forever is a cool anna karenina reference but a little bland compared to the other songs on here



anna is awesome tho, and i really like greg's voice on this

America is definitely the best single imo, one of my faves here

Album Rating: 4.0

absolutely zero punch?! there were a couple songs where he reeeally packs a punch, but I'll have to listen again to remember which ones

Album Rating: 2.5

"Anna" sounds like an autogenerated Menzingers song in the same way that "Day I Day" sounded like an autogenerated National song to me

Album Rating: 4.0

Anna is the AI greg song and Strawberry Mansion is the AI tom song.

""Anna" sounds like an autogenerated Menzingers song"

yeah... I turned it off after that. Gonna try again later but what I've heard sounds pretty stale, and I am not a fan of the production at the moment.

Album Rating: 4.5

Anna is still my favorite song on here

Album Rating: 2.5

"Anna" sounds like an autogenerated Menzingers song [2]



This album makes me sad, i loved this band.

Album Rating: 2.5

"absolutely zero punch?! there were a couple songs where he reeeally packs a punch, but I'll have to listen again to remember which ones"



eh it's all pretty tame and the vocal production even further drowns it out

Yeah, production is whack. Not coming around to this one like I'd hoped. Like it while it's on, but nothing really draws me back. I guess we'll always have 'On the Impossible Past'.
:-/

Album Rating: 2.5

And RW, and ATP. This is very likely the beginning of the downward spiral that most bands take. If it was earlier on in their career id say they could bounce back, but when you have a dud on album #6, that usually means thats that. Oh well, 3 amazing albums and two good ones, they had an unforgettable run.

Album Rating: 4.0

His vocals in Anna's prechorus are some of his best ever

"I guess we'll always have 'On the Impossible Past"

Yeah no doubt. Album is timeless. Anytime I get antsy listening to ATP or this now, I just go back to OTIP and it never disappoints

Album Rating: 3.5

Lyrically Anna is great though. I still love the studio apartment line.

Album Rating: 3.0

omfg the AI comment was ridiculously accurate

Album Rating: 4.0

four classic albums and one great album*

they have some good songs, agreed

Album Rating: 4.0

OTIP = ATP > this > RW

OTIP >>>>>>> everything else