Pink Floyd Wish You Were Here
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Tyler.
November 9th 2014


19035 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

UnpopularOpinion

ArsMoriendi
November 9th 2014


42336 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

"Dark Side? No way."



Agree to disagree I guess?

Jots
Emeritus
November 9th 2014


7632 Comments


@shark - lame joke on my part, nvm.
@tempest - yeah man I know.

ArsMoriendi
November 9th 2014


42336 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Futures just did something Lakes. would do, weird.

tempest--
November 9th 2014


20634 Comments


it was a joke

Frippertronics
Emeritus
November 9th 2014


19720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.8

yeah



check You're Dead!, it's everything you would want in an electronic album

























well if you're fine with a Snoop Dogg and a Kendrick Lamar verse or two, considering this is you we're talking about.

SharkTooth
November 9th 2014


15014 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I'mma look for something to criticize for you

Mongi123
November 9th 2014


22454 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Ugh I hate the "ok here me out" type of talk like your saying in the first paragraph. Don't say this shit, and stand firmly by your opinion. I have no idea who's alt this is, but this is very poorly back. You really generalize the main selling point of this album and people listen to this for many many different reasons. The concept of the terrible demise of a friendship, the love of old prog, the atmosphere, the emotion, what have you. It's all different. Plus you don't have any arguments for some of the songs having lazy song writing in paragraph three. You just kinda say they're lazy and leave it at that. Pretty much, this reads harsher than a 3 and the points aren't backed up well. I don't give a fuck about this being Pink Floyd, but this review just has me scratching my head the entire time.

Frippertronics
Emeritus
November 9th 2014


19720 Comments

Album Rating: 3.8

eh whatever, he listens to most of the stuff I rec him. Unlike you, surprisingly...

















love ya man

SeaAnemone
November 9th 2014


21427 Comments


"Fair enough, but do you think people would try throwing out insults to the writer or mass neg simply for this exact calibur of writing if it fell in line with their opinions? Of course not, do people hold it to a higher standard? I'd say yes. The hivemind makes me not want to ever review on this site."


"throwing out insults to the writer"
wait where is that happening lol? I'm seeing some very mild insults towards the review and more just surprise at his opinion

"mass neg"
3
"mass"
3

would this review have gotten the same attention? no, obviously not? nobody is arguing it would... how is this "hivemind"?

why wouldn't people more closely scrutinize something that doesn't line up with their opinion? people generally have reasons for their opinions. maybe they went into this review looking to better understand the other side, and this review -because let's face it, it's not very good- left them wanting.

in what world do you live in where this is at all due to some "hivemind" phenomenon lol?

SharkTooth
November 9th 2014


15014 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I reread the review to check for anything wrong and came across this:



I'm eagerly stressing is if we take away this obsession, nostalgia and iconic power they have, will the music still hold its own ground?



when you stress something, you are trying to emphasize a point not ask a

question
please fix

Jots
Emeritus
November 9th 2014


7632 Comments


@eric - I agree... actually. I've seen negative-ish reviews of lauded albums that were actually received well due to the writing. I guess people are more likely to scrutinize a review of an album like this, which should prompt the writer to be exceptional in his arguments

UnpopularOpinion
November 9th 2014


26 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

@shark cool thanks.I'll sort that out and proof read it soon

ArsMoriendi
November 9th 2014


42336 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

""mass neg"

3

"mass"

3"



Actually 5 people neg'd it now.

Mongi123
November 9th 2014


22454 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Seriously though, who is this? I'd like to know just cause. But yea that was the word I was looking for: Vague.

420YoloSwag420
November 9th 2014


65 Comments


"Futures just did something Lakes. would do, weird. "

so he came out of the closet?

tempest--
November 9th 2014


20634 Comments


this review has lazy and sloppy writing but im not going to go into any further detail youre just gonna have to believe me

omg its like im UnpopularOpinion!

SharkTooth
November 9th 2014


15014 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

So I've started listening and holy fuck is this guitar solo cool

UnpopularOpinion
November 9th 2014


26 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

haha beej. oh yoooou

ArsMoriendi
November 9th 2014


42336 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

"so he came out of the closet?"



Nah, he linked an avi, which Lakes. does like 10 times a day.



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy