The key issue with the review is it commits the subjectivist fallacy. It doesn't state that you personally don't like Kid A, which would be fine, you assert that its a bad album and you let your dislike of it pollute the review.

i'm content with assuming their first album is really bad

Album Rating: 3.5

It's cool we'll just agree to disagree but like HolidayKirk said i'll "stick to my guns" and still think that Rainbows is a much better album than it's predecessor Kid A

Even if I dont think In Rainbows is better than Kid A, I would rather listen to In Rainbows 9 times out of 10.

Album Rating: 4.5

"Radiohead rises from the ashes of their past 3 albums"



Neg'd

Album Rating: 3.5

Man soo many negs haha. Lesson learned: never talk bad about Kid A album. Or any Radiohead album for

that matter

Album Rating: 4.5

dont worry i posd.





and thats all you need

Album Rating: 4.5

I don't understand why people say Radiohead is tune-less or doesn't have any melody. There are plenty of unique melodies in even their weirdest material.

never talk bad about Kid A album.

^^

No. Wrong. Do talk bad about Radiohead they could use a kicking every once in a while. Just dont make assertions. When you come down stating opinions as fact people are going to rail you for it.

And like, actually work on your review. If you're going to talk bad about an album people generally love you need to seriously make detailed and well drawn criticism. This doesnt cut it. At all. You deserve every neg.

Album Rating: 4.0

shut up kirk

Album Rating: 5.0

No one said you can't have an opinion. You just don't give valid reasons as to why you don't like Kid A in the review. Save that for a Kid A review because the comments you made about it were uncalled for.

Album Rating: 3.5

So if I never said anything about Kid A, would this be a decent review?

Album Rating: 4.5

It's not a horrible review, but not really worthy of a pos. Too much time spent talking about the band's history and why Kid A sucks, and not enough on the music.

Album Rating: 5.0

Yea there's always room for improvement. I'm still far from perfect. Just try to focus on this about the album you are reviewing rather than why you dislike their past work.

Album Rating: 3.5

Okay duly noted. I'll make a better review next time. I did spend a lot of time talking about Kid A.

Album Rating: 4.5

ive read this review about 20 times now, and i can safely say good sir that you made a good review good sir

Album Rating: 3.5

Lol I can't tell if that's sarcasm or not but i'll take it.

Album Rating: 3.5

'for your information I studied music theory in collage. I played guitar for almost two years. I have a keen ear on what sounds good and what goes well together.'



My new motto

This thread makes me embarrassed to be a music theory major...

Album Rating: 3.5

You sure it makes you embarrassed? Or did you just want to boast on your credentials..