Album Rating: 4.5

@eclipse, that actually sounds about right. Sci fi feels wiser, more reflective etc, while Daisy is wild, aggressive, experimental and rambunctious.



I honestly probably would have preferred Daisy at some point but, in my mid 30s now, Sci fi just speaks to me more.

Album Rating: 4.5

Sci fi And TDAG are my favorites and pretty damn close — both 5s. Deja is next for me — 4.5. Then Daisy 4, and YFW at a 3 (I think).

Album Rating: 4.5

Top three are Devil and God, Daisy, and Sci Fi on my end.

Album Rating: 4.5

@tectactoe I have 0 nostalgia for YFW, just find SciFi very long winded, inconsistent quality-wise (2 or 3 amazing songs and the rest of the tracklist is just serviceable), and pretty boring by the standards theyve set for themselves

Album Rating: 4.5

YFW is overhated. Its nothing special but its still a good piece of early 2000s Pop Punk. Jude Law and A Semester, The Shower Scene, and The No Seatbelt Song fuck gud.

@TheWonder; that’s fair, my comment was kind of dickish, I meant more from a personal perspective, YFW would only rank higher-than-last if I was feeling incredibly nostalgic that day. But your criticisms of SF are fair, and I can totally see how some of the tracks kind of muddle into the middle ground below the handful of standout tracks.

Album Rating: 4.5

Mixtape is another solid track off YFW.

Album Rating: 4.5

@tectactoe I didn't think your comment was dickish at all, just wanted to provide a rebuttal haha

To be fair, if I was a lyrics person, I'd like SciFi more. But lyrics mean absolutely nothing to me if I dont click with the music first

Soco is by far the best YFW song

Album Rating: 5.0

Agreed

Album Rating: 4.2

Nah its gotta be jude law

Album Rating: 4.2

tbf I probably haven't heard that album in 4 years

Hot/weird take: Logan to Government Center is best YFW by some distance.
(And not to be mistaken, I *like* YFW, I just think it ended up paling in comparison to their subsequent releases; for some reason, for me, it doesn’t have the longevity that everything else has to some degree.)

Album Rating: 4.2

I thought everyone agreed with that last bit

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah it’s just not nearly as good as their other albums. And honestly not very representative of them as a band overall.

Album Rating: 4.5

yeah no Soco runs circles around the rest of YFW, though Logan to Gov't Center is relatively underrated (I'd take it over Seventy Times Seven, personally)

Album Rating: 4.5

Soco is one of the weakest off of YFW imo

Album Rating: 4.5

It’s about smack dab in the middle for me. No Seatbelt and Mixtape are probably my two favorites.

*sigh* Here we go again, why delay the inevitable.

S: Logan to Government Center
A+: Soco Amaretto Lime
A: Magazines; Mix Tape
B+: Last Chance to Lose Your Keys; Secondary
B: Jude Law and a Semester Abroad; Seventy Times 7
C+: The Shower Scene; Sudden Death in Carolina
C: The No Seatbelt Song
D: Failure By Design

Album Rating: 5.0

S: Logan to Government Center

B+: Secondary



D: Failure By Design





allright i think ill be leaving this thread