Album Rating: 4.0

cant compare the two, they aim for completely different things. you gotta rate things based on what they are, not compared to everything else. dream theater takes themselves seriously, periphery don't.

Album Rating: 4.0

"I just dont see the justification in giving this the same score as images and words for example."

Wonderfully insightful comment from a user whose favourite Dream Theater album is When Dream and Day Unite.

Album Rating: 3.5

“50% talking about the album. 30% "band sux lol". 20% complaining about "band sux lol". Not bad by periphery thread standards.”



And 1% talking about Blood Eagle’s killer groove

Album Rating: 4.0

'tis a sweet groove.



There, now it's 2%

I've never listened to a periphery album more than twice, it's just not for me.

but I've been stuck on this since its leaked.

Wonderfully insightful comment from a user whose favourite Dream Theater album is When Dream and Day Unite.

When dream and day unite isnt a bad album. I just dont see how you can give this the same score as images with a straight face. Im open to other opinions.

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Images doesn't do it for me the way this does, so there's that.

Debating the merits of a periphery album with dream theater ratings. I really think that says it all.

Album Rating: 2.5

oof

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Yes, good album agreed

Album Rating: 4.5

Wonderfully insightful comment from a user whose favourite Opeth album is Morningrise.

Debating the merits of a periphery album with dream theater ratings. I really think that says it all.

Op brought it up not me. Its also a massive difference in terms of quality, inventiveness, memorability

What are the odds that anyone will still remember what this is twenty years from now?

Album Rating: 2.5

most albums will never be remembered tho

Album Rating: 4.5 | Sound Off

Images doesn't do it for me the way this does [2]

Album Rating: 1.5

What are the odds that anyone will still remember what this is twenty years from now?



I can get behind that. That applies to pretty much every genericore, indie and djent release out there.



Wonderfully insightful comment from a user whose favourite Opeth album is Morningrise.



There's almost no wrong answer to what the best Opeth album is. Unless it's one of the last three or Ghost Revs. In which case, please gtfo

Album Rating: 2.5

Morningrise is also a wrong answer tho

I thought that one of the chief perks to listening to Opeth was that it didn't matter what your opinion on their best album was?

Morningrise is perfect fite me irl fgt

Tbf Morningrise is unpolished as hell but is more appealing that a lot of supposed top tier Opeth. Has a lot of their best moments.

“Wonderfully insightful comment from a user whose favourite Dream Theater album is When Dream and Day Unite.”

The latter is actually good though. It’s unnecessarily shit on when it’s better than anything DT have done in the past 15 years