Album Rating: 5.0

Treefingers doesn't need raindrops :P

Little raindrops, Little raindrops, Little raindrops

Album Rating: 4.5

5's aren't albums with no skipping tracks - theres only one album I consider has five songs of 5/5 quality and that's Infected by The The. The rest of my 5's have three or four 5/5 tracks.



The rating I give an album isn't the average score of the songs on it or anything like that. It's the overall effect and the good songs usually have more of an impact than the average or bad songs.

Agreed. No album is perfect.

Album Rating: 5.0

I have several: Kid A, Sunbather, Bloom, The Everglow, The Mantle, and I Was Searching and I Found, and yes this too. Others too but those are just from my mind



Those are albums I would list as "perfect" or "flawless"

Album Rating: 4.0

Boxer by The National has only one song I'd rate below 4.5 but other than that what doof said.

Album Rating: 5.0

I think The Everglow is one of the few albums where I'd rate every track a 5. But I think y'all are taking what I said dramatically. A 5/5 is one I can listen to and enjoy from start to finish. Ever track doesn't necessarily need to be a 5 but the overall feeling does. But I just said Fitter Happier keeps OKC from being a 5 smh. No one says "oooh! Fitter Happier!" But same can be said about "Treefingers" but to me the creepy ambiance of Treefingers felt more like a track than Fitter Happier. You could cut Fitter Happier out and it be the same album. Treefingers just has this ominous feeling to it to where you know what's gonna happen but you're just gonna calmly wait it out anyway

Album Rating: 4.5

I don't have any album where every track is a 5, but I still have a number of albums I consider perfect. For the most part my 5s have tracks ranging from 4-5/5 individually, but I can think of a handful that have a 3.5 or two thrown in the mix. No 3s, though, I don't think.

Album Rating: 3.1

Kid A is a 5 with a 2-worthy song on it, for me

"But I just said Fitter Happier keeps OKC from being a 5 smh."
"You could cut Fitter Happier out and it be the same album."

huh...

Album Rating: 4.0

There are only two albums where I think every track is a 5: OKC, and The Weakerthans' Left and Leaving

Album Rating: 3.0

They were amazing live



I don't have a album where i think every song is 5/5 but there are quite a few albums where the songs are atleast 4/5

Album Rating: 4.5

i think reco site is better than left and leaving tbh

also i've settled on my rating for this, listened again last night and it kinda blew me away, it's so beautiful

In Rainbows would be perfect without House of Cards and maybe less repitition on Videotape

Album Rating: 3.0

videotape is actually a 5 song

Videotape is close to a 5 but there's legit like 30 seconds that don't feel needed on the song.

Album Rating: 5.0 | Sound Off

Videotape is perfect the way it is

Meh. It's like...the 8th best song on the album but I'd say all those 8 are perfect.

Album Rating: 4.5

House Of Cards is one of my faves. It just takes me somewhere that's really hard to explain.

What the f**k Magician? That is one of their best songs. It's perfect.

Meh, House of Cards is the worst song on that album imo. But it has nice guitar work.