Father John Misty Pure Comedy
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
guitarded_chuck
May 16th 2017


18070 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

"Kind of an obnoxious attitude towards people liking something you don't like, no?"



no, it was in direct response to ash admitting he overrated this initially



and beyond that, even beyond music if you'd like, it's just the truth

supremejelly
May 16th 2017


1264 Comments


Are you saying going from 4 to a 3.5 means that your initial judgement was biased from being part of a cult?

"and beyond that, even beyond music if you'd like, it's just the truth"

Okay I'll make sure whenever I need an opinion on some music I'll ask you since your opinion is the truth and all

guitarded_chuck
May 16th 2017


18070 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

thats not what im saying



ash came into it with a bias based on some preconceived admiration for the artist he had in his mind already



" Okay I'll make sure whenever I need an opinion on some music I'll ask you since your opinion is the truth and all"



k this is way more obnoxious than anything i've said itt, going to extremes immediately like an emotional trainwreck

supremejelly
May 16th 2017


1264 Comments


I changed my comment because yeah I think I took that out of context. My bad

No it's not more obnoxious, you're saying that your opinion of this album is bad is the truth. I'm not going to any extreme, just taking what you said.

guitarded_chuck
May 16th 2017


18070 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

no i'm not fucking saying that at all and frankly i'm done with this conversation because it's over your head

supremejelly
May 16th 2017


1264 Comments


"and beyond that, even beyond music if you'd like, it's just the truth"

Based on this and what you said before, it sounded like you were saying that it's the truth this album is bad. Just misunderstood you.


guitarded_chuck
May 16th 2017


18070 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

fair enough no i was talking about cults in general there, people prop things (people, politicians, places, ideas, religions, art, etc) up in their mind for whatever reason and will begin to perceive their output irrationally in order to defend what they have consciously or otherwise chosen as an ideal in the face of criticism

supremejelly
May 16th 2017


1264 Comments


Yeah that makes total sense and it was dumb of me to miss that lol. My bad dude. You're spot on.

I think sometimes a rating bump/decrease is from having more time to digest the album too. That's why I don't rate an album until it's been out for atleast a month. Too many times have I loved/hated an album at first, just to see it differently only a month later. Can be from picking up on stuff I hadn't noticed before, the album finally "clicking", that kinda thing.



guitarded_chuck
May 16th 2017


18070 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

no worries my bad too and for what it's worth i'm only human and i'm guilty of doing that sort of thing at times too



i'm usually good when it comes to music at trying to come into even my favorite artists with cautious optimism but it happens, i remember at first i wanted tlop to be better than it was for example

AmericanFlagAsh
May 16th 2017


13689 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5 | Sound Off

Nothing wrong with changing ratings when you listen to it later. I like rating albums after one listen for my initial thoughts and then to see how it changes.

supremejelly
May 16th 2017


1264 Comments


That was my experience with Gore, I was so pumped to listen to it, and throughout it I felt like I was trying to convince myself it was good. Held on to that fantasy for some time until I realized one of my fav bands released a dud. It's a huge disappointment when that happens, it can be hard to admit it to yourself sometimes.

^that's true, nothing wrong with that. For me though I'm just afraid I'd forget to update the rating later on

Conmaniac
May 16th 2017


27771 Comments


haha I never finished this....

luci
June 3rd 2017


12844 Comments


this will show up on very few year-end lists. seems like even the fanboys have lost interest
for an album that tries to say a lot it's quite irrelevant

rabidfish
June 3rd 2017


9004 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

it's irrelephant lolololo

klap
Emeritus
June 3rd 2017


12410 Comments

Album Rating: 3.1

if by sputnik end-of-year lists, i'd probs agree. it will be huge on a general critical level once end of year rolls around

JohnFire
June 3rd 2017


987 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

Quite annoying how everyone that doesn't like this has to pretend this is the worst thing ever and everyone hates it. You don't get it. Fine. Move on. I still love it and always will ¯_(ツ)_/¯

JesusCage
June 3rd 2017


452 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

'Quite annoying how everyone that doesn't like this has to pretend this is the worst thing ever and everyone hates it.' x2



I think it's damaged expectations from the ones who where expecting ILY,H2

theNateman
June 3rd 2017


3809 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

I still want a ILYH2

TwigTW
June 3rd 2017


3940 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

The hate is strong on this one. Never really figured out why, but that makes sense I guess.

Conmaniac
June 20th 2017


27771 Comments


I never finished this and probably never will. my loss? probably not, this was pretty boring



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy