Album Rating: 2.5

I’d say Open Water and Lost Continent are the two standouts, but yeah, everything is good and kinda washes over you. Night Diving is awesome also.

Album Rating: 3.5

The Flame Deluge is the unrecognized GOAT of that EP imo. Absolutely crushing

Album Rating: 2.0

KISS THE COALS

BREATH IN SMOKE AND I SAY

"HERE I AM, SEND ME"

Album Rating: 3.5

Fire is just one massive standout track. Messenger makes me want to run through a wall.



Water has *two* standout tracks: Night Diving, and the Whaler. If anybody tells you they don't like The Whaler, they're a cop.

Album Rating: 3.5

yeah The Whaler is like top 5 Thrice songs imo

Album Rating: 3.0

TAI is the complete antithesis to this. it's heartfelt, authentic, sincere, compassionate. this sounds like a bot wrote and composed it. it's entirely soulless. how? just how is that possibly the exact same band?

Album Rating: 3.0

Hopefully Palms is to Thrice as Cope was to Manchester Orchestra and they come back with an absolute world-killer of a record.

Album Rating: 2.5

"Water has *two* standout tracks: Night Diving, and the Whaler. If anybody tells you they don't like The Whaler, they're a cop." [2]



Night Diving is Thrice going full-on Isis, which is really, REEEAAAAALLLLY more along the lines of what I was wanting post alchemy index. Instead we got a barrage of pretty good alt rock albums (aside fro Palms, which is bad).

Album Rating: 2.5

the messenger is the best song they made since vheissu and honestly it isn't even close.

Album Rating: 3.0

i actually thought the same when i was 12 years old

Album Rating: 3.0

TAI in general feels like it has a ton of ISIS influence



ISIS and Radiohead

Album Rating: 2.5

Alright, but only because everyone was asking:



1. Water — Just beautiful, stunning and serene. Some of their finest work. (4.5)



2. Fire — Firebreather is in my top five Thrice songs so that elevates this a bit for me — but I also love The Messenger and the atmosphere on The Flame Deluge is so great and eerie (4)



3. Air — this is spotty for me and had to grow. Broken Lungs and A Song for Milly are stunning songs and Daedalus is solid (very overrated tho imo — a 3.5 for me — the last minute is great but the rest is a little dull). Don’t care for the other songs much. Silver Wings is so slight and pointless. (3.5)



4. Earth — this isn’t bad by any means, and I love The Earth Isn’t Humming, but I guess the style of music here doesn’t really appeal to my tastes. Tbh I really need to revisit because I only listened twice — a few more spins might help. (3)

Album Rating: 2.5

I love how Palms is so bland that we just discuss other Thrice albums lol.

Album Rating: 3.0 | Sound Off

yeah The Whaler is like top 5 Thrice songs imo [2]



Fire > Water > Air >>>>>> Earth

Album Rating: 3.0

I miss pre hiatus Thrice

Album Rating: 2.5

I don’t consider The Whaler to be one of the highlights off Water tbh.



Open Water

Lost Continent

Night Diving

Digital Sea

The Whaler

Kings on the Main



Still good though.

Album Rating: 3.0

I have never liked Fire quite as much as others here for whatever reason. Every song is good and all, but I can't tell you what song is what on it without hearing it first.



Digital Sea, Night Driving, and Whaler are my favorites from Water, but the whole EP is just magnificent.

Album Rating: 3.5

I saw Thrice last night and seeing a few Palms helped my overall appreciation quite a bit. They still got it and Dustin's definitely screaming again.

Album Rating: 2.5

I saw them last fall and it was definitely a great show. Some of the Palms tracks did come to life and shine in a live setting.

Album Rating: 3.0

Beggars is severely underrated here. It's up there with Vheissu as best Thrice for me.