Album Rating: 4.5

mmh nah

Album Rating: 4.5

never really considered Protest the Hero to be metalcore tbh

shai hulud's that within blood ill-tempered guys

Album Rating: 4.5

"Fortress by Protest the Hero is the pinnacle of melodic metalcore, guys"



"oisincoleman64"



can't even be counted

Album Rating: 4.0

fortress wow lol



is it even melodic metalcore

Album Rating: 4.5

uh yea

Album Rating: 4.0

i always thought of it as prog-ish metal with core tendencies. dont hear any melodeath influence at all like there is on this and other melocore

it is melodic metalcore yeah but it's so all over the place it's hard to consider it a pinnacle of anything

To me anything Protest the Hero ever created is pretty much insufferable tbh

wow really?

Well some of their albums seem to get a decent amount of love on sput

theyre pretty good yea

i mean im not crazy about them or anything but i would probably take any pth album over every kse album. even scurrilous

just for reference, not that theyre necessarily similar

Album Rating: 4.0

no pth album even touches this tbh

see its crazy to me when i see so much hate for slaughter of the soul but so many people defending this

pth is one of those bands i used to love a lot but am afraid of listening to because i feel i wouldn't dig them nearly as much now :/

Album Rating: 3.0

definitely an album

"see its crazy to me when i see so much hate for slaughter of the soul but so many people defending this"

that's because the general consensus is that melodic metalcore is bullcrap and slaughter gets the hate from the dm community because they "sold out"

yea i know theres always been retards in metal but still