Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah let's not pretend that Air and Earth aren't a step below

Album Rating: 4.5

and even those two have some incredible moments



I love The Sky is Falling, Milly Michaelson, Silver Wings, Come All You Weary and Child of Dust



but As the Crow Flies and 2/3 of Earth, I could do without

Album Rating: 5.0

Come All You Weary has some immaculate vibes

Album Rating: 4.0

god, this whole thing is so good. might actually get into this band this year.



i think ive listened to this in full like *thinks and sighs* thrice. only really came back to Earth Will Shake and Red Sky when i was first dabbling with these guys. looooooooooved For Miles on my first listen and havent come back til this year (and first listen was HS i think so over a decade whooops). but really, such a strong album front-to-back.

Album Rating: 4.0

and once again For Miles is perfectttttttt

Album Rating: 4.5

they played that song live when I saw them earlier this year. I was straight swooning. it's one of my favorite songs ever

Album Rating: 5.0

I need to see them but they never tour norcal other than SF and it's such a circus seeing shows there

Album Rating: 5.0

For Miles, The Earth Will Shake and Red Sky are all perfect songs, agreed.



Of Dust and Nations and Atlantic are close.

Album Rating: 5.0

I saw them once here in LA on the Palms tour, it was actually my last show before Covid hit (maybe 3 months before).

Album Rating: 5.0

“what's all y'alls favorite thrice albums



This, followed by Fire/Water (firebreather best song ever) and Major/Minor (super underrated).

Not as big on Air/Earth. Some good tracks scattered across, but find both to be inconsistent.



Beggars and Artist rule too.

Album Rating: 4.0

@Larkin, those are def the top 5 on here. Between The End and Stand and Feel Your Worth are def up there too



still just really getting into them, listened to air/earth today for the first time (Air good! Earth ehhh)

Fire is like everything i love about the heaters on this but the intensity is just dialed to 11, god.



Artist is dope, i just stylistically prefer this.



i think i heard Major/Minor in full at some point? Anthology is def my fave by them if not For Miles. pretty sure i really liked the album



remember thinking Beggars wasn't anything special but i don't remember a single thing about it



i remember the closer on Palms being good but the rest being ehh



and yeah, we'll see how the Thrice journey goes from here!

Album Rating: 5.0

Yeah the bookends on Palms are good and…that’s about it lol.



Give Beggars another listen for sure. It’s a grower.

Album Rating: 4.5

Need to jam this masterpiece again.

Album Rating: 5.0

Not one mention of Illusion of Safety 😔

Album Rating: 4.0

let me relisten to artists first, then i'll either illusion of safety or beggars depending on moooood

Album Rating: 4.0

If you like Major/Minor you'll almost certainly like Beggars. The opening track threw me off for a while but I can live with it now.



Palms gets rekt everywhere but to me their only stinker is To Be Everywhere. Palms has the bookends + The Grey, Just Breathe, My Soul. The rest is OK. Hold Up A Light definitely not great, sounds like it should have been on TBE ¯_(ツ)_/¯

Album Rating: 5.0

Illusion of Safety is a decent album for sure — Deadbolt, See you in the Shallows, To awake and Avenge the Dead and the Beltsville Crucible are all solid. But some of it is just kind of meh to me. And I do not like Identity Crisis.



Artist is where they started making 3.5/4 music imo.

Album Rating: 5.0

If you like Major/Minor you'll almost certainly like Beggars. The opening track threw me off for a while but I can live with it now.



I would expect that as well. I prefer M/M, but more seem to lean towards Beggars as being the superior of the two.

Album Rating: 4.0

i'm still so obsessed with this atm. love the level of technicality on here. it's very apparent but not in your face

Album Rating: 5.0

Illusion is a 4 at minimum, Artist is damn near 5 territory already