I get what you mean, the overall which I read was good (besides some gramatical/spelling errors), but still good job so I'll vote.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0
I don't mind the review. No i didn't read the whole thing, but you LIED saying this wasn't MoP :mad:
Meh I wrote a paper that was 22,000 words before :-/
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
but you LIED saying this wasn't MoP
Yeah, I didn't want people to know until it was out. Sorry for the deception and whatnot.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.5
that must have sucked to have another MoP review come out the same day that you put out your massive review for MoP.
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.0
Haha a bunch of the reviews were deleted.
|
| |
Nice 50th! MoP, of course...
|
| |
man thias has so many fucking comments. but yeah plath said it good when he said calm down.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.5
Well, it's been over a month and you've filled me in on your status every day, and today I finally got to see it. I read every one of your reviews, and to be honest, you did a wonderful job.
Examplory work, Andrew. :thumb:This Message Edited On 10.20.06
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.5
Spat must have deleted some of these reviews. Its about time.
|
| |
yeah there was a shitload of them. also sorry for being a review whore but: http://www.sputnikmusic.com/album.php?reviewid=9636&page=1#lastpost
i also just read the court one and i enjoyed good job, i'll probably end up reading all of this ereview eventually.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
i also just read the court one and i enjoyed good job, i'll probably end up reading all of this ereview eventually.
I'd recommend skipping the TBT.
|
| |
Mammoth effort! I do think however you will have alienated some readers due to the length (even though the option was there to choose your "pleasure"). I skim read most of it, it seems you spoke about the same thing time and time again. This is obvious since you were reviewing the album, but I saw a comment before suggesting perhaps a better idea would have been a concept per issue. Maybe try that for Ride the Lightning (I did check your profile... I know it is the only one left) given its good points would suit an "argument" review (perhaps metalhead on a blinddate with tart-girl), the bad points would suit a trial review, and an opposite review to underline the extreme good/bad points. Throw in an overview, and perhaps a tbt on your favourite songs and it would be a refined version of this. If you don't do it I might steal the idea...
|
| |
My review's gone wtf :p
Who cares anyway, mine was crap.
|
| |
Album Rating: 5.0
Mammoth effort! I do think however you will have alienated some readers due to the length (even though the option was there to choose your "pleasure"). I skim read most of it, it seems you spoke about the same thing time and time again. This is obvious since you were reviewing the album, but I saw a comment before suggesting perhaps a better idea would have been a concept per issue. Maybe try that for Ride the Lightning (I did check your profile... I know it is the only one left) given its good points would suit an "argument" review (perhaps metalhead on a blinddate with tart-girl), the bad points would suit a trial review, and an opposite review to underline the extreme good/bad points. Throw in an overview, and perhaps a tbt on your favourite songs and it would be a refined version of this. If you don't do it I might steal the idea...
Yeah, I did re-state the same things, but that was mainly because people were only supposed to read one of the reviews, or like two at the most. For some reason a lot of people read the whole thing. Oh well. Anyways that is a pretty good idea about RTL, but if I do, do it it won't be for quite some time. This isn't the kind of review I'm just gonna thorw out randomly, too much effort. Perhaps I'll make it my 100th.
|
| |
I'd recommend skipping the TBT
yeah i dont think i would be able to sit still for the amount of time it would take me to read one of the track reviews because lik each track description is a review.This Message Edited On 10.21.06
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.5
Jesus Christ MM8, this review is probably the longest in Sputnik history, this is without a doubt the longest I have seen. I don't know what to say but this was too long for me taste, sorry.
|
| |
read the intro^ its 6 different reviews. also ive never seen you in my short time at sputnik and you're an approved reviewer. nor have i seen any of your reviews.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.0
this review is amazing.
|
| |
nice 50 review, i stopped reading about halfway through because it was so long. i like other albums by Metallica more but this is still good
|
| |
Wow holy big ass review. How long did this take you?
Anyway, you get a pos because you're one of the only original reviewers on the site, and most of the time you're original ideas are good. most of the time.
|
| |
|
|
