Meshuggah I
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Emyay
March 10th 2014


6282 Comments


could try having an open mind betray

betray
March 10th 2014


9392 Comments


I have an open mind about in all my musical endeavors.

Until the same riff is constantly played for 1-2 minutes straight

Emyay
March 10th 2014


6282 Comments


except its not the same riff tho bc polyrhythms

betray
March 10th 2014


9392 Comments


nah it's literally the same shit for minutes at a time


this vocalist may also be the worst metal vocalist ever as well

climactic
March 10th 2014


22921 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Until the same riff is constantly played for 1-2 minutes straight



lol. i guess youd hate most black metal, doom, drone, post-rock, post-metal, etc then!

Insurrection
March 10th 2014


24856 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

this vocalist may also be the worst metal vocalist ever as well




how the fuck

Emyay
March 10th 2014


6282 Comments


check them ratings

BigPleb
March 10th 2014


65808 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

This is incred.

Emyay
March 10th 2014


6282 Comments


Carnifex Die Without Hope
Like others have said, if the band that released this album wasn't Carnifex, elitist nerds would be
eating this up.

^betray you're too concerned with shit like this. you're being close minded bc you think 'elitist
nerds' are being close minded about shit you like. you gotta realize at some point that none of that
matters. its cool if you don't like this but why come here to antagonize in the same way that you've
been antagonized for your core-leaning tastes

betray
March 10th 2014


9392 Comments


How?

He has no range what so ever. Drones on in the same tone (which isn't even good to begin with) the
entirety of this song/ep/whatever

And no, I wasn't trying to antagonize. I REALLY thought that liking Meshuggah was another Lil B.

CalculatingInfinity
March 10th 2014


9941 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

"I REALLY thought that liking Meshuggah was another Lil B."



Is this guy for real? Jesus christ.

betray
March 10th 2014


9392 Comments


But more or less, you're right. In a way.

It just baffles me how the same kids that say core music is generic and all sounds the same can turn around and praise Meshuggah who have essentially released the same album like 6 times.

Emyay
March 10th 2014


6282 Comments


lol aight then. i'd like to hear your reaction to something like portal

Emyay
March 10th 2014


6282 Comments


or deafheaven. you would REALLY hate them

CalculatingInfinity
March 10th 2014


9941 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

"It just baffles me how the same kids that say core music is generic and all sounds the same can turn around and praise Meshuggah who have essentially released the same album like 6 times." *1's all of Meshuggah's discography*



Not gonna lie, this made me laugh hysterically.

Propose
March 10th 2014


959 Comments


@Betray: Meshuggah is awful agreed, repeating riffs doesn't make music bad though because Sunn O, Portal and Swans rock but those bands have atmosphere, songs with purpose and interesting compositions while Meshuggah is just devoid of anything even remotely interesting.

Emyay
March 10th 2014


6282 Comments


dude he gave the debut ep a 1.5 cut him some slack

climactic
March 10th 2014


22921 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

betray is dum

Emyay
March 10th 2014


6282 Comments


he wouldn't like sunn o))), portal, or swans guarenteed

Propose
March 10th 2014


959 Comments


At least he's smart enough to see how awful this band actually is



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy