Album Rating: 3.7

Marrow grew on me a lot over time and is definitely only a minor step down from Ashes

Album Rating: 3.0

i'd take marrow over ashes as well

Hell, I think I'm even starting to dig To Drown. The sense of dread in that track is crushing. It used to be the fatal flaw of Marrow for me but now I kinda see its purpose

Album Rating: 3.7

Your black metal is showing Art

Album Rating: 3.5

Marrow is second best tbh

Album Rating: 2.5

ashes>mantle>marrow>pf>this

Album Rating: 3.7

Ranking time y'all



The Mantle=PF>Ashes>Marrow=The White>FE>Stone>Oak>Serpent



Everyone should hear their split with Nest, incredible neofolk like The White

Album Rating: 3.5

I need to hear their eps now that I think of it.

Mantle>White>PF>Marrow=Ashes>FE>OSWP>This

Album Rating: 2.5

i don't care what people's rankings are because i can understand why one would like one of their lps over another. except for this. this is so damn terrible

Album Rating: 3.7

Scream is the only user I know of who considers this one of their best, he even wrote a review justifying it.

Album Rating: 2.5

yikes

I wrote a review too ;) album is underrated

Album Rating: 3.7

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores

Source Rating

Metacritic 84/100[4]

Review scores

Source Rating

AbsolutePunk 8/10[5]

The Austin Chronicle 4/5 stars[6]

Exclaim! 10/10[7]

Metal Hammer 6/7[8]

Metal Storm 8,3/10[9]

Pitchfork Media 8.3/10[10]

Slant Magazine 4/5 stars[11]

Spin 8/10[12]

Sputnikmusic 2/5[13]

Tiny Mix Tapes 3.5/5 discs[14]

The album received mostly positive reviews.



Maybe on here but nowhere else haha

Album Rating: 3.0

"Exclaim! 10/10"



the fuck is wrong with those guys?

lmao. this is definitely not their best album. the first track rules hard but everything else is pretty meh

Album Rating: 3.7

I enjoy most of this, it's just underwhelming overall. I wonder how many of those reviewers have heard any of their previous albums lol

Album Rating: 3.8

Yeah not even close to their best. First 3 albums are all classics and Marrow rules too. This is good, but yeah it can't compare to the others in any way.

Album Rating: 2.5

i don't trust metal publications and blogs AT ALL. i don't think they have much integrity or actual taste. i feel that way about most music publications in general, but from what i've seen, metal criticism is the most lacking

Album Rating: 2.5

like sputnik yeah