I think the original versions of the singles on this sound WAY better than the rerecording's, like idk what happened with IKYWT on the rerecording but it feels like its missing something. Overall rerecording is way better though

I knew u were trouble when u walked iiiiinnnn

Album Rating: 4.0

The 2.9 avg is way too low

The singles slap.

Album Rating: 1.0

Is it

Album Rating: 2.5

I don't like the lyrics as usual but the album is better than a lot of her stuff I've heard, I never got why this one is more hated

I didn’t realize this was hated

bonkers average

Album Rating: 4.0

^ Late reply, but I think the avg comes from a few things:



1. Sowing's 2/5 review, which was the first staff review that came out for the album back then. And at the time, the staff rating had a lot more pull in regards to the overall album avg (see: Paramore s/t review)



2. Despite being well-received by critics when it came out, a lot of people weren't happy with Taylor's shift toward straight-up pop music. Especially after Speak Now, which many would argue was the peak of her country era



But, given the reception for Taylor's Version on here, I don't think the avg represents the general opinion as much anymore. But this is also my favorite TS album, so maybe I'm biased 🤷

Album Rating: 1.0

It’s too high agreed



Respectfully



But I will say that sowing 2ing this and 5ing the new one is insane dissonance

Album Rating: 2.0

I still think this is her worst

just found out this album is in the top 50 of all time on RYM, holy shit