Album Rating: 4.0
^ Late reply, but I think the avg comes from a few things:
1. Sowing's 2/5 review, which was the first staff review that came out for the album back then. And at the time, the staff rating had a lot more pull in regards to the overall album avg (see: Paramore s/t review)
2. Despite being well-received by critics when it came out, a lot of people weren't happy with Taylor's shift toward straight-up pop music. Especially after Speak Now, which many would argue was the peak of her country era
But, given the reception for Taylor's Version on here, I don't think the avg represents the general opinion as much anymore. But this is also my favorite TS album, so maybe I'm biased 🤷
|