Album Rating: 4.0

Zero Sum is the second

Album Rating: 3.5

The Warning

The Great Destroyer

The Good Soldier

God Given



Honestly most of Year Zero

Album Rating: 3.5

I will claim The Warning is the best NIN song until I die

Album Rating: 3.5

I always found With Teeth more exhilarating than the previous albums.

best nin song is big come down

Album Rating: 3.5

OMG I just found this: https://www.nin.wiki/Recurring_lyrics



Someone actually documented how much Trent recycles lyrics

lmao woww

Album Rating: 5.0

lmao I was straight nerding out when Add Violence dropped with all the With Teeth and Year Zero callbacks. so corny but I love that shit



best NIN song is La Mer agreed

Album Rating: 3.5

I like La Mer, but I always saw it more as a prelude to Into the Void



Also, I LOVE Into the Void

Album Rating: 5.0

not really a prelude, I mean it's longer than Into the Void lmao. they're sister songs, same as The Great Below/Underneath it All, and probably a few more on The Fragile

Album Rating: 3.5

"I mean it's longer than Into the Void lmao."



(This is for you Potsy, cuz I know you're gonna call me out for um actuallying, but)

UM ACTUALLLLY, it's shorter, but barely



"La Mer" - 4:38

"Into the Void" - 4:50





I think he was trying to make them pretty much the same length though, so I can go with sister songs

Album Rating: 5.0

ashcckhakcually the definitive remaster (which I'm going with cos... it's definitive) has La Mer at 5:10

Album Rating: 3.5

"the definitive remaster"



You mean the 2017 remaster that cuts a minute of Ripe (With Decay) off? Do people even listen to that version?



Doesn't count, not the 1999 release everyone knows and loves

Album Rating: 5.0

it's legit the best-sounding album in my entire collection. every DE has sounded superb, Trent knows what he's doing. also as if you're gonna pass up extended mixes of a bunch of songs + The New Flesh in its rightful place on the tracklist

I love Hand That Feeds, it's a great industrial rock song

Welllllll aacchktyouuhhhllleeeeeey

Album Rating: 3.5

You're barking up the wrong tree, Row



One of my main complaints about this album is that it's way too fucking long for its own good, so yeah I'm pretty sure I'd hate that he made some of the songs longer



I also don't like "The New Flesh" at all, in fact, it's worse than like any song that made the original album, even the absolute space waster "The Way Out Is Through"

Album Rating: 4.5

Big comedown is like top 10 material

So is the last two tracks on fragile disc 2

Album Rating: 4.5

La Mer is absolutely amazing, as is The Great Below.



The Big Comedown is the best track on disc 2 for sure.

Album Rating: 4.0

Dam I thought I was the only one whose fav fragile track was the big come down