Poison the Well The Tropic Rot
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Ray91
March 20th 2026


1140 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

Weeping Tones is a highlight for sure. Bad Bodies kills as well

Ectier
March 20th 2026


5096 Comments


Jamming new one to see what the fuss is about

Ray91
March 20th 2026


1140 Comments

Album Rating: 4.5

it's about the slappage

Ectier
March 20th 2026


5096 Comments


Certainly is unga bunga throw hands core.

Eh new albums pretty meh, glad folks enjoy it and the band came back but this aint my jam

ShartHarder
Contributing Reviewer
March 20th 2026


909 Comments


i went in expecting to not be so into the new one, but its surpassed my expectations after first spin. its some manly gruff badass shit

pourradass
March 20th 2026


1200 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Funny I'm currently at Weeping Tones and so far it's my only sore point, that melo chorus doesn't feel right

pourradass
March 20th 2026


1200 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

first impressions: it's short, and front-loaded. Probably won't top Tropic Rot for me but should be a 3.5 at a minimum. Will definitely spin again and get familiar

jrlikestodance
March 20th 2026


8575 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

New one is a nice blend of everything leading up to this point. Very impressed they still got the sauce after so long out of the game

Larkinhill
March 20th 2026


8836 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

That Wake of Vultures outro into Bad Bodies intro is fucking exquisite. One of the best moments on an album this year thus far.

JayEnder
March 20th 2026


23265 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Bad Bodies is so fucking good.



Absolutely love the new record man they delivered so hard

Jebull
March 20th 2026


1531 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

That Wake of Vultures outro into Bad Bodies intro is fucking exquisite. [2] - couldn't agree more, yeah Bad Bodies rules

artificialbox
Emeritus
March 20th 2026


3905 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

"first impressions: it's short"



oh fuck 42 minutes is a short album now?? 😭😭😭

Larkinhill
March 20th 2026


8836 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah dude I’m in fucking love with this album. 2 full listens in.



Only PTW album I still have to check out is TTR. And I definitely want to spend much more time with this (obviously), TOOD (the only one that hasn’t fully clicked but I do like it, and do so more each spin), Versions for sure and a little more TFTR. Gotsta check out their EP too.



Already got my ticket for the LS show in may! PTW. Converge (love what I’ve listened to but I’m very very much looking forward to my first discog run with them). And The barbarians of Cali. I mean, DAMN. Always loved The Library, and been liking every song I’ve heard of theirs so far, bout a half dozen.



This is most definitely THE show of the year. The can’t miss. Not with that lineup. You can’t afford to.



Larkinhill
March 20th 2026


8836 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

42 mins — pretty par for the course average runtime for them.



Works perfectly here. Never drags. Doesn’t feel slight in the…slightest.

Larkinhill
March 20th 2026


8836 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Alright, here I go double-triple posting again. I’m a fucking writer tho, sue me! I like writing so I get wrapped up in it and the thoughts just keep hitting.



BUT—I digress…



Tbh the one thing that could keep me from 5’ing this, and the one issue I really have, is that final track. At 10 mins, by far their longest (unless there’s one on TTR). I thought we were getting a truly fucking epic closer. But…about half of that is silence in the middle, and the end is pretty underwhelming. Maybe it’ll grow on me. But it’s a shame that such a phenomenal record just peters out like that. Reminds of Deftones self titled and Moana, Deftones diamond eyes and this place is death (literally every song before it fucks, and risk + 976 evil is such a high point…then this place is death feels so anti-climactic.



Ok enough from me. Time for more poison the well.

Larkinhill
March 20th 2026


8836 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

More from me.



So far I feel the first 7 tracks are where this is strongest. Final four are solid but not as good. SO FAR. These guy’s music tends to grow.



But weeping tones-wake of vultures-bad bodies feels like the strongest stretch — which is the middle of the album. Unusual.



Weeping Tones is beginning to look like the clear winner here for me, and possibly in the utmost upper PTW echelon.

JayEnder
March 20th 2026


23265 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

Quadruple post. Respect.

Jebull
March 20th 2026


1531 Comments

Album Rating: 3.5

Hahaha dude you basically already reviewed it

Larkinhill
March 20th 2026


8836 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0

šŸ˜†



Well, listened through again. And I couldn’t have been more wrong about the 2nd half. It’s epic. The first half is def more in your face and immediate though.



And I’d say Weeping-Vultures-Bodies PLUS Drifting is the strongest stretch.



Once I accepted the final track was really two songs, not one, I was more receptive.btw 2nd ā€œpartā€ of Plague starts at exactly 6 mins in. And it ends perfectly. Soaring and emotional, it’s the perfect ā€œsend-offā€.



This is simultaneously an immediate record and a grower. The best type of album, and the type that more often than not ends up being the most enduring/classic.



Yeah this could very well be a 5.

Flugmorph
March 20th 2026


35592 Comments


Everything Hurts rules



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy