Album Rating: 4.5

Acidicity, though I love Metallica and this album, you are SOO wrong. This album has such a lack of diversity and many of the tracks sound pretty similar. I still enjoy it greatly though. Way more diversity in power metal than thrash

Album Rating: 4.0

guys you know the only reason Trivium is better than Metallica's St. Anger is because anything is better than St. Anger, right? So the fact that you pick Trivium over any St. Anger song says more about St. Anger than Trivium.



also ace album

Album Rating: 4.5

SHIT!!!!This Message Edited On 01.08.07

Album Rating: 5.0

Damn a lot of opinions here . But i must say i love this record. Sure the production could be little better(!?) but i somehow like the way it sounds. It's so damn angry! Crank up the volume and it feels like a fucking beating(dyers eve!). To me it's very progressive if you look at their other albums. All the tempo changes and that.

Felt it sounded a bit repetitiv when i first got it, and it kinda is sometimes, but now i don't really mind. oh and the lyrics are superb. Any how i just have to say good review and it's nice to see a different opinion. oh oh and i don't like trivium 'cus of their singing, i don't really like hardcore growling at all but anyway...

That's cool. I used to really like this as well a few years ago, so I know where you're coming from. Blackened is still a great song.

The rest just got really old for me over the last few months. =/...

Haha, truth.This Message Edited On 03.21.07

Album Rating: 5.0

Blackened is probably is my favorite song on and justice for all.

Album Rating: 5.0

title track is still excellent . but nowhere close being as good as blackened. Harvester of sarrow is a great song as well.

Album Rating: 4.0

...You guys suck, obviously One, Dyers' Eve and Blackened are the best. :/

Album Rating: 5.0

well...didnt you see that iI put the song blackened down...and harvester of sarrow is a great song.

Album Rating: 4.0

I really like the album but can see why others might not.



There's the production issue, and I never truly got used to the drum sound, but there are instant classics here. EOTB & TSS are the only songs I never really got into totally.



TLITD has some of the most brilliant guitar interplay, and I love Hetfield's scorching delivery (particularly the verses in the title track).

Album Rating: 4.0

Yeah, Harvester of Sorrow is decent.

Album Rating: 4.5

you state "avoid this whenever possible"



but yet you gave it a 2.5 which is average



why is an average album to be avoided whenever possible?

maybe he was being generous you know what that is don't you AMERICA HATER

Album Rating: 5.0

Interesting review but...

i dont agree at all

Album Rating: 4.0

Even though I don't agree with all it, this is a good review. I personally enjoyed this album. The length never bothered me; there was enough variation in the long songs (Besides "Frayed Ends of Sanity") to keep me interested. But everyone has their own opinion; to each his own.

Album Rating: 4.5

Ballsy review, and well written. I couldn't disagree with you more though.

Album Rating: 4.5

awesome album good review

This is their best album ever. master of puppets dragged on ,where as this one kept things busy and me interested

I have RtL and MoP and this is probably the only other Metallica album I would ever get. From what I've heard, this was their last good album. I don't really know anything about the S/T though...do they still have their old sound on that album?