Album Rating: 1.5

Haha love that summary. Dogshit album/band

Album Rating: 1.5

glad someone mentioned that haha. felt fitting.

Great review man, overall this is very nicely written and you make a lot of lucid criticisms. All I’ve found are some small nitpick-y things to fix:

> Smashing together the music that was popular at the time and metal together isn’t a new thing,

One redundant “together”

> Cohesiveness is just thrown out the window and while messiness can be charming in certain circumstances but this definitely isn’t one.

Need a comma after window, get rid of “but” and replace that with a comma too.

> Don’t worry the extremely forced, juvenile and edgy anti-religious lyrics show up here…

Some punctuation after “don’t worry” is needed, your pick. Oxford comma after “juvenile” (optional).

> Some may find this innovative but in reality it just feels like trendhopping to appeal to children, which does fit the embarrassing lyrics admittedly. It might not be but what’s worse, appealing to 14 year old girls to make more money or this being an actual genuine artistic expression.

The last sentence is a bit awkward because it’s not full, because “it” refers to the subject of the last sentence, and it looks like a rhetorical question which still needs a “?”. I’d re-work it.

Overall, this is quite well done for a lengthy review, pos’d hard m/

Album Rating: 1.5

thinking back to this. i am terrified about the butchery that is going to happen. i swear if they take a classic and put this sheen of disgusting paint over it i'm going to riot.

Album Rating: 2.5

didn't know you reviewed this!

Album Rating: 1.5

this is the album that really inspired me to start writing again actually because i was so mad haha! i think it might be my best work, had a lot of fun with it.

Album Rating: 4.0

Well…shit. I barely gave this a cursory listen when it came out, but been on a BMTH kick the past few days and decided to give it another whirl.



I….kinda like it? Had it at a 2.5 before. Not sure it’ll grow to a 3.5 but possibly…that’s a big possibly though.



The first half is actually really solid, but the 2nd half has some ROUUUUGH tracks for sure. Even difficult to get through. We’ll see if those grow on me at all but, I doubt it.



Youtopia to Lost is a pretty solid stretch though. Youtopia and Limousine in particular stand out.



I think Lost, Strangers and R.I.P. are the ones I hated — esp rip.

Album Rating: 4.5

Lost is so good though



Agreed on RIP I cut that up so it's just the final 23 ish seconds because it leads well into Amen and Strangers I usually keep on because it's alright but I have a version where I cut strangers and die4u and it ends up being a 43 minute really solid album (I also cut the final 2 minutes of nothing of the closer)

Album Rating: 4.0

Gonna give SH another listen as well, sorta same. I didn’t give it much attention. While I liked some tracks off amo, there was plenty I didn’t like, and aside from Doomed, Drown and (sorta) Throne, TTS was a boring, bland slab of stadium rock.



Those two albums really just killed much interest I had in this band going forward. And I don’t think this album changes that too, too much. But we’ll see.

Album Rating: 4.0

I might be wrong on Lost, wasn’t sure if that was one of the tracks I disliked or not. The other two I’m sure of though.

Album Rating: 4.0

Damn. This is actually their third highest rated LP. That’s really surprising.

Album Rating: 1.0 | Sound Off

god damn i hate this album and the way the song titles are written makes me so pissed. OLD MAN YELLS AT CLOUD.

Album Rating: 1.5

absolutely dreadful stuff!

Album Rating: 4.0

I DO hate how the song titles are written, it’s very cringe and kind of pretentious even.



@groundking — I was wrong about lost, relistened and like that one. RIP is offensively bad though, and die4u is pretty awful as well. This really is a pretty good album though lol, I think I like more on this than I do on amo and TTS, but TTS beats it simply based on having a few really high highs (everyone knows of what I speak, it’s blatantly obvious which songs I’m referring to).

Album Rating: 2.5

worst album cover of theirs which is saying something

Album Rating: 1.5

it is truly sickening but fitting for this dreck!

Album Rating: 4.0

lol. No disagreement here. Though SS, while kinda cool cover, is fairly edgelord/cringe. But…still kinda cool lol.



TIAH is def coolest/best BMTH cover. Amo has a cool one too.

Album Rating: 1.5

yeah i actually dig suicide season. really love the composition with the white background and black dress. just pops.

I like the character design on this one (though Sof looks better on the Lo-files cover, the anime-esque graphic style suits them better).

Agreed about TIAH, my second favourite would be TtS. I love minimalistic monochrome icon artworks.

Album Rating: 4.0

Holy shit, this is REALLY growing on me. I may even bump to a 4, but I could listen a handful more times and it kinda wears off a little, and I land back on a 3.5. So I won’t bump it yet.



I don’t know. Shit is definitely a grower for sure. But it sinks its teeth into you. Definitely their best album since Sandpit Turtle (def not on its level though). And I am not into pop music at ALL so it’s kinda surprising I’m liking this as much as I am.