I always suspected they were a commy plot agreed

Album Rating: 3.5

basically DEP but strictly pop punk with prog influences

Album Rating: 4.0

Listen to Ribbons & Sugar, probably their best stuff

Album Rating: 4.5

I love this album so fucking much

I love YOU so fucking much

Album Rating: 4.5

haha the love is shared! I can remember that I went to Warped Tour and saw them play like 2 songs and loved them and picked up this cd and a poster of the cover from their merch table and it blew me away

literally every second of this album is a breathless hook

Haven't listened to this in years and years but they were definitely one of the best bands of their day

Album Rating: 4.5

listened to this for the first time since like probably 08-09 and it still held up perfectly so i had to 5 it

Album Rating: 4.0

Been bumping them a lot lately. Criminally underrated, and it's sad they couldn't get their shit together to do another one, the few new tracks they ended with were pretty great.

Album Rating: 4.5

CURE ALL MY HUNGER

IN 3 MINUTES AND 30 SECONDS

Album Rating: 4.5

Holy fuck. We got new Gatsbys American Dream in 2025. What the actual fuck. This is real.

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah, insanely hyped

Album Rating: 4.5

Lost It reminds me more of The Money Pit than GAD but the other two songs are classic Gatsbys, especially when that riff kicks in halfway through Pitter Patter. Ready Player Two is the best of the three IMO. They just need to get Bobby back in the band for the full effect. The EP art even has little dudes holding signs saying "Where's Bobby?"

Album Rating: 4.5

Didn't know Bobby wasn't involved with the new stuff, thats a shame

Album Rating: 4.5

Yeah he hasn't been part of any of the reunion stuff as far as I know. All their band photos from the past few years have just been 4 of them with no Bobby.