Album Rating: 3.0

I looked at their setlist for this tour and tbh it doesn't have any of my favorites from Material or BBH. I never got into cex cells and I thought this was fine

Whoaaaa the opening of Infinite Skin sounds so much like something early Depeche Mode would have done

lol infinite skin fucking bumps

i feel like this band has a great album in them but its not quite there yet. there are some moments of synthpop brilliance here

ill put it like this...

i like when i can hear all depeche and no afi

Album Rating: 1.5

It so wasn't my thing. Had potential too... Pity!

Album Rating: 4.0

Damn, it's a shame that the wider exposure this is receiving isn't gathering it more love. Makes me realise that this must just be appealing to a very peculiar taste around here. I love this thing.

Album Rating: 4.0

as do i

I warrrrrnnned youuuuu!

Album Rating: 4.0

Favs: Infinite Skin, Unstained, Ok Alex, Dark Arcades



The only one that feels like a dud to me is Maker. Otherwise this is super solid and my fav BA.



Summer... feels like it is nearly an AFI song.

Album Rating: 4.0

Caroline isn't clicking with me and I wish Matrimony and Dust had a little more going for it but I love the rest.



Dark Arcades is perfect. I'll probably have a solid ranking by the month's end.

Album Rating: 4.0

Caroline has probably been the biggest grower for me. Dark Arcades is, yeah, the album highlight.

Album Rating: 4.0

this 3.1 average makes me sad. i'm still loving all of it.

cexcells was decent but i hated the follow-up and stopped checking their new stuff. maybe i should try this

Album Rating: 4.0

Still the best synth-pop I've heard all year. Anyone who finds that ridiculous is welcome to rec challengers!

Album Rating: 3.0

Bright Black Heaven was the most "AFI sounding" which is probably why it is my favorite. I thought this one was fun, but didn't have the staying power. All I revisit is Infinite Skins and occasionally ok alex (which is pure fun).

Album Rating: 4.0

Dark Arcades is still a hard top 5 track of 2019

Album Rating: 4.5

love this album and have been getting really into this project lately. it should have been higher on my list

Album Rating: 1.5

How is it decided which albums will feature on the homepage as a year-overview? It surely can't be general popularity or appreciation if this was featured with a 3.2 average and only barely over 40 ratings/ 3 pages of comments...



In other words: why has this popped up again on the homepage?

Album Rating: 4.0

Because Sput is built with a little used objective aesthetic value detector, and someone triggered it, causing it to detect the high aesthetic value of this album, and voila, it's on the front page.