Madonna Rebel Heart
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
Koris
Emeritus
January 18th 2018


22621 Comments


@RippingCorpse: I fucking love this part from his Fly by Night review:

"Songwritingwise, they're addressing the real-life documentarian concerns of a young hungry rock band in such non-fictional road life accounts as "Fly By Night," "Best I Can" and "Making Memories," as well as mentioning...umm..."elves" (THANKS NEIL) in "Rivendell," a colossal fight between an evil being and a snowdog in -- now see, here's my problem with analyzing Rush lyrics. I don't have a background in geek loser dorkdom. So I can read lyrics like "By-Tor & The Snow Dog" and think to myself, "Oh, he's singing about so-and-so, it appears to be a metaphor for blah blah blah," but chances are that Neil is just referencing some gayass role-playing board game or faggotybutt book about pixies that people read when they're eight years old and wear glasses."

bloc
January 18th 2018


70880 Comments


YOU ARE BEAUTIIIFFFFFUUUUULLLL

NO MATTER WHAT THEY SAAYYYY

DinosaurJones
January 18th 2018


10414 Comments


THE LINE STARTS HERE

RIGHT IN FRONT OF ME

BECAUSE THERE'S NO LINE

RippingCorpse1986
January 18th 2018


3229 Comments


Really love his Rush and Yes reviews.


From his Tormato review:
""Arriving UFO" starts off hokey, but jeez does it get noisy when the aliens show up! And "Release, Release" is their spastic attempt to play a normal upbeat rock 'n' roll song. They can't do it! They can't even stay in 4/4! They know it's too boring, so they have to make it as complex as humanly possible. Fantastic and hilarious. Complete with a moronic "live" drum solo. Silly kids. A mostly enjoyable record, but extremely fruity, and completely immature in almost every way. Rick Wakeman's dumbass beard, for example."

RippingCorpse1986
January 18th 2018


3229 Comments


Plus, his review of British Steel by Judas Priest is fuckin legendary

swipenet
January 18th 2018


3388 Comments


Lol are all these negs coming from the same guy's alts? The pacing seems a little suspect.

DinosaurJones
January 18th 2018


10414 Comments


Wow, those negs built up fast. Damn.

WatchItExplode
January 18th 2018


10705 Comments


what do you expect with such an edgy take on a beloved artist?

RippingCorpse1986
January 18th 2018


3229 Comments


This review is fucking glorious man, the negs are bullshit

Dedes
Contributing Reviewer
January 18th 2018


11981 Comments


I mean its really not that great as review because half of it literally is him being angry that someone who lost their sex appeal is trying to have sex appeal, I mean I guess I understand but for that to be 80 percent of the reason you hate an album???

DinosaurJones
January 18th 2018


10414 Comments


Is Madonna really all that beloved though? At least on Sput?

EDIT: Just checked album scores... I guess I'd give that a tepid "beloved..."

swipenet
January 18th 2018


3388 Comments


I'm not saying a neg or two is surprising, I'm just saying it's pretty suspicious that basically 10 negs in a row came so quickly, especially in defense of album with a fucking 2.5 average. I'm simply willing to bet that there are alts at play.

Dedes
Contributing Reviewer
January 18th 2018


11981 Comments


Dude
These are NOT alts at play lmao
It literally is just a very flawed review


RippingCorpse1986
January 18th 2018


3229 Comments


The review had like 13/13 yesterday and now is 18/28 wtf

swipenet
January 18th 2018


3388 Comments


It was 17/17 actually, and now it's 18/28. Some gremlin is at work here.

Dedes
Contributing Reviewer
January 18th 2018


11981 Comments


Did you just call me nigga
Do you know me lmao

Dedes
Contributing Reviewer
January 18th 2018


11981 Comments


Idk, it's hardly bad enough to warrant that many negs imo simply because there are parts that actually do paint me a decent picture of the album, perhaps I just more so strongly disagree with why he didn't like the album, which is kind of stupid but I guess not neg-worthy.

swipenet
January 18th 2018


3388 Comments


Probably not, what's good though? Does a common term used to address online acquaintances hold any meaning to you?

DinosaurJones
January 18th 2018


10414 Comments


MY DUDE

swipenet
January 18th 2018


3388 Comments


Yeah exactly, it isn't inherently poorly written. I'm really just more impressed that someone is willing to go to this length to defend Madonna on Sputnik of all places (in the very likely event that all these negs are indeed related).



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy