Album Rating: 4.5

I've never understood why he sounds so out of breath during that chorus, considering he's held higher notes so much better

used to enjoy them more than opeth...but gotta say opeth is more consistent to me

Album Rating: 4.0

nice pt ratings brendan :]



pt vs opeth is a tough match-up but otsol is too weak so i'll say opeth

I like MAYH, Still Life and Morningrise more than any PT album.

i might be the only one who prefers otsol to the incident but still both are inferior to any opeth for me.

otsol is terrible, probs shouldn't even be a 2.9 or whatever it is.

Album Rating: 4.0

orchid vs otsol: orchid

morningrise vs up the downstair: utd

mayh vs tsms: mayh

still life vs this: still life

bwp vs stupid dream: bwp

deliverance vs lbs: lbs

damnation vs in absentia: tied

ghost reveries vs deadwing: tied

watershed vs foabp: watershed

heritage vs the incident: the incident



opeth 5 - 3 pt

i have otsol at 3 and the incident at 2.5 : D

Theres too much filler but songs like Radioactive Toy are some of Pt's best

orchid vs otsol: orchid
morningrise vs up the downstair: morningrise
mayh vs tsms: mayh
still life vs this: still life
bwp vs stupid dream: stupid dream
deliverance vs lbs: lbs
damnation vs in absentia: in absentia
ghost reveries vs deadwing: ghost reveries
watershed vs foabp: watershed
heritage vs the incident: heritage

7 - 3 in Opeth's favor

Album Rating: 4.0

radioactive toy and nine cats are really the only otsol songs worth mentioning

orchid vs otsol: orchid
morningrise vs up the downstair: morningrise
mayh vs tsms: mayh
still life vs this: still life
bwp vs stupid dream: stupid dream
deliverance vs lbs: lbs
damnation vs in absentia: damnation
ghost reveries vs deadwing: ghost reveries
watershed vs foabp: watershed
heritage vs the incident: heritage
opeth 6 pt 2

didnt like any song out of the incident it just bored from start to finish,it seemed lifeless tbh

Album Rating: 4.0

the incident would be a 4 for me but the 2nd disc is just too good

nil recurring is a pretty sick EP (the drumming especially is... outstanding), normal is a great song.

Album Rating: 4.0

gavin is a beast agreed

Normal is a better version of Sentimental. Should have been on fear

Album Rating: 4.0

normal is amazing but sentimental is one of the highlights on foabp imo so idk if they should've replaced it with normal

"heritage vs the incident: the incident"

dshajfjshehhdairghirgf

Bought the 2CD version of this today, it was the only one of thier psych era (including EPs) that I didn't own on CD besides their debut which I probably won't bother with.