I just noticed that you are a Contributor. Dear god you don't deserve the tag with this review. I'm legitimately shocked.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.0
Stfu please, thanks
|
| |
Awesome rating pizza, have a pos'!
|
| |
Though my dislike for the band comes from personal reasons I enjoy people having different opinions : )
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.0
What a nice guy
|
| |
There's a huge difference between "this kinda reminds me of ____" and "this album is obviously a ____ ripoff"
|
| |
0_0
didn't peg Deviant as one who had 5'd this, strange.
|
| |
@ Lucidity: So because I do not particularly enjoy this album, and stated it in this review, I must not deserve to be a contributor even though that's what critics do: state their viewpoints. I see.
I think he was referring to the writing
|
| |
didn't peg Deviant as one who had 5'd this, strange.
why not? It's electronic ;)
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
This is album is like stereogum
I'm thinking that if you wrote this review in exactly the same way, but with a positive view on the
album, you would have a lot more positive votes.
|
| |
Ahhhh I always forget how far reaching Radiohead's various experiments were!
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.0
why not? It's electronic ;)
haha : )
|
| |
Don't assume I'm dismissing you because you don't enjoy the album. I'm dismissing you because this a terrible review: your logical reasoning is unintelligent, you make shallow observations, and your tone is seriously ill-chosen and condescending (which is a spectacular failure since you don't have the reasoning to back up this 'arrogant critic' shtick). Your criticisms don't go any deeper than this is 'bad', 'sub-par', 'filler', 'boring' etc. Take this paragraph section to illustrate what I've pointed out:
Kid A is not entirely awful, Radiohead just seem to lack the ability to know when they’ve created something bad, or sub-par, or filler. Therefore we hear songs like ‘In Limbo’, ‘Morning Bell’, and ‘Motion Picture Soundtrack’, which are aimless, boring, forgettable filler tracks. But Radiohead didn’t simply leave the album with only sub-par songs, oh no. They crapped out confusingly atrocious songs like ‘Kid A’ and ‘The National Anthem’ that are experiments gone wrong, ending up more irritating then interesting.
You say absolutely nothing worthwhile here and just appeal to redundancy to get your point across. Radiohead don't know when they created something bad or filler. Therefore we have X songs that are bad and filler. Simply stating a chain of opinions does not constitute a review, which is the biggest problem I have with this write-up. This is only made worse by your tone (look at the first sentence I quoted) which really does you no good when targetting a popular album. I'm not telling you to be nice or apologetic, but if you don't have a strong foundation for your arguments then don't bother with the condescension.
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.0
Wait a sec, will respond after I take a shit.
Jk. Dude, chill
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.0
nice review 
|
| |
Album Rating: 3.0
I think it was a good review. A little more detail in some spots. One correction
|
| |
Album Rating: 2.0
@ Lucidity: yeh sure whatever
|
| |
Whats with everyone bashing The Radioheads lately? I mean, their no Muse, but their still a good band.
|
| |
I mean, their no Muse, but their still a good band.
lolololololol awesome!
|
| |
Album Rating: 4.5
Okay, Pizza... I was ready to leave this well enough alone but your last comment made me compelled to
chime in once more. "Sometimes it's difficult to get it together due to my ADHD, but I do try my best
and often succeed." This sounds like a refuge for a person who just can't take the heat, and it's
followed immediately by you patting yourself on the back. Seems to me like you're putting yourself out
there in a way that suggests we should pity you, and that's a little bothersome, because you and I
both know well and fine that you're capable of much better. You've written longer reviews in the past
with ease, so I don't appreciate you falling back on that. Too many people do this. Sorry if that
sounded harsh.
|
| |
|
|
