Album Rating: 4.5

MAN you guys are old!



The first musician I remember dying was Kurt, and while I was a little sad, as a Nirvana fan even then, I was really too young to dwell on it. I was nine.



I feel so young right now...I thought I was one of the oldest people on this website...

Album Rating: 3.5

Old age it's in the head. The average age of sputnikers is pretty young, it's undeniable.

i listened to this

thought i was lkistening to back in black

^^^ so much win

Album Rating: 4.0

I really should listen to this more. I can never see myself giving this a 5 (I much prefer BiB, but Bon Is my favourite ACDC singer go figure :S) I adore the first 4 or so songs on this but I just can't sit through the whole thing as easily as Back in Black.

Album Rating: 4.0

Your 9 years old...?

Album Rating: 4.5

WhiteNoise. There is SO much wrong with your first post, I won't even begin to detail what. BiB is the most overrated piece of mediocre lazy-ass music making ever. This is a career-defining album. No comparison.

Album Rating: 4.5

You really have a strong opinion on AC/DC, don't you Pedro? BiB is the only excellent Johnson album.

Album Rating: 4.5

I find it hard to listen to a Brian Johnson song after listening to a few Bon Scott songs, know what i mean?

Haven't been on here in a while so only just seen this. Another great review for a classic album, pos'd.

Album Rating: 4.0

whoa I was just expressing an opinion dude.

Album Rating: 4.5

So was I.



And yes, Nag. I admit they're far from perfect, but I love them anyway. And I can't STAND the worship for BiB (or FTATR for that matter).



If this one has three fillers (which I detailed above), BiB has: What Do You Do For Money Honey, Given The Dog A Bone, Shake a Leg (awful), Let Me Put My Love Into You, and Have a Drink On Me (as much as I like it, come on, it's far from a classic). One could even arguably include Rock'n'Roll Ain't Noise Pollution on this list, even if it is a fan-favorite.



So yeah, while the remaining five songs are all classic and above-par, would you really rate an album with 60% filler 5/5? If you rate Nevermind as a 3 "just cuz", then don't rate this one a 5. Quit being hypocrites and just admit: BiB may be historically important, but it painfully average.

Album Rating: 5.0

Wow, easy!

On the "I love BiB"-subject, I agree with WhiteNoise - Back in Black is probably my favorite album. But I also love Highway to Hell. Just because a guy doesn't have quite the same opinion as you, you don't have to jump him right away. Geez...

Album Rating: 4.5

Sorry, fanboy in me coming out.



I respect opinions, but one has to be objective. I see a lot of subjectivity towards this and Nevermind, pulling in opposite directions, so I was just contributing an objective analysis.

Album Rating: 4.5

Sometimes it sounds like you expect nearly every song on an AC/DC album to be a classic though.

Album Rating: 4.5

Nah. But this ensemble is stronger than BiB's.

Album Rating: 5.0

Although I can see your point, I don't agree - well, I do on the "Nevermind"-album matter, but not BiB ;)

Back in Black is just classic Rock n' Roll - legendary!

Album Rating: 4.0

" One could even arguably include Rock'n'Roll Ain't Noise Pollution on this list, even if it is a fan-favorite"



OK man, THAT is too far! hahaha. Noise Pollution and Givin' the dog a bone are fantastic.

Album Rating: 4.5

Given The Dog a Bone is the second weakest track after Shake a Leg.



R'n'RANP is great - I love it! - but by no means a classic. As I stated, it's a fan favorite!



We still have about 50% worth of filler, which makes the rating for this album a 3.0 AT BEST.



A 5.0 can have at most one filler song (see: Ktulu on Ride the Lightning, She's Got Balls on High Voltage, Coming Clean on Dookie, Endless Nameless on Nevermind, To Tame A Land on Piece Of Mind, Aphrodisiac Jacket on Electric, The Sun Is Burning on Wednesday Morning 3AM) or ideally none.

Album Rating: 4.5

Wut, Ktulu is one of the best moments on RtL and To Tame a Land is a classic Maiden epic. The weakest track on Piece of Mind is very easily Quest for Fire, perhaps even the worst Maiden song ever.