Green Day American Idiot
» Back to review

Comments:Add a Comment 
morrissey
Moderator
October 4th 2005


1688 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

This album is actually pretty decent. I'm not a huge Green Day fan but it's definitely their best album. The singles are overplayed to the point that I never want to hear them again though.

Electric City
October 4th 2005


15756 Comments

Album Rating: 4.0 | Sound Off

"Don't get your panties in a knot cause I don't like your favorite band."





I'm not getting you panties all knottesd cuz u dont like green day. I could really care less. But calling out people and being a jackass for no reason is really not what sputnik music is about. You call out Green Day and try to pick fights with them by saying really untrue things about them. And ok it's a loose punk rock opera i understand that, but at least they had the balls to try something new anyway. This Message Edited On 10.05.05

vicy77
October 5th 2005


164 Comments


The song american idiot is great and true. Americans are all just stupid. Italy rules

vicy77
October 5th 2005


164 Comments


also, the media overplays this shit so no one will like it after some time and many actually begin to hate it, otheriwse everyone would agree its a great album. Fuck the media


_unknownST
October 8th 2005


256 Comments


well there i go

cheeto-t do do u kno if W.M.U.W.S.E is long or not

Jawaharal
October 8th 2005


1832 Comments


W.M.U.W.S.E.?

_unknownST
October 8th 2005


256 Comments


im not i hope im just asking a question to do with the album,

W.M.U.W.S.E = wake me up when september ends

Jawaharal
October 8th 2005


1832 Comments


the music video is like seven minutes the song is like 4

wikuk
October 9th 2005


1110 Comments

Album Rating: 3.0

I like this album, i would give this a 4/5. this album takes punk-rock to a higher grade and showing people there are more ways to be punk than just creating fast short easy songs.

F**k Forever
October 9th 2005


19 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

I really hate this record.It's a pathetic attempt by them to revive their careers.They're just riding the 'Anti-Bush' bandwagon.Utter bollocks.

francesfarmer
October 9th 2005


1477 Comments


Revive their careers.....

F**k Forever
October 9th 2005


19 Comments

Album Rating: 1.5

That's what I said.

francesfarmer
October 9th 2005


1477 Comments


Their career wasn't exactly that underwater in the first place.

BasketCase2649
October 11th 2005


22 Comments


all right this comment is for people like Cheet-O or what ever his name is

this is a punk rock opera yea punk rock, you see the whole message is not to believe everything you see on the news and in the media, Green Day is not anti america because they realize that if it werent for america they could have never done what they love to do

second of all dont say theyve gone mainstream all of a sudden because just about every other album except Warning and their early EP's were Mainstream

another thing is that they have been political for a while songs such as Minority, and Stuck With Me are examples

o and Good Charlotte and what not were trying to copy Green Day and have even said so so dont accuse them of trying to be popular and copy sucky bands

pulseczar
October 11th 2005


2385 Comments

Album Rating: 2.5

Billie Joe Armstrong needs to learn how to play guitar before I bust a cap in his white ass.





word.

I'm Charming
October 12th 2005


332 Comments


Green day is terrible. All their songs are like based on 3 guitar cords.

kolzig33189
October 12th 2005


335 Comments


nothing wrong with 3 chord rock. alot of bands have done that. i personally think green day sold out but their old stuff which happens to be 3 chords is still good

kolzig33189
October 12th 2005


335 Comments


yes actually they are different now. they totally chnaged their sound to make it poppy(ex-boulevard of broken dreams). and becuz its "cool" now they use way too many refernces to politics

Storm In A Teacup
October 12th 2005


45784 Comments

Album Rating: 5.0

I happen to agree with 1039/Slappy Hours. While not a huge Green Day fan I find it stupid for people to call them sellouts and people have done that since Dooky. My buddy(sort of) who likes rap only(he's a wigger) says their sellouts because they singed to a major label, which is the most fucking stupid thing to say, making it worse, he's only heard stuff from American Idiot. Same thing is happening again to Green Day for American Idiot, granted Billie Joe is taking it to far (ex. Live 8), but they tried something new and it worked out great for them. My dad who is a republican agrees with me about this too even though he hates the band.

Kotor1505
October 13th 2005


1 Comments


I think its stupid for people to say that Green Day is bad (or whatever they want to say about them) just because their music might be different than it used to be. So what if they are more political, i mean really it doesnt make a difference to me what they are like now or used to be as long as they continue to make good music. If people dont like the new direction that Green Day has taken well thats their problem for not liking the music. It bothers me when people say that Green Day has gone "mainstream" as if it was a bad thing. All it really means is that Green Day made their music a little different and a lot of people liked it that way.The people that don't like it anymore get all upset about it over nothing. If you don't like the music don't listen to the music. It's that simple. i agree with 1039/slappy hours.This Message Edited On 10.13.05



You have to be logged in to post a comment. Login | Create a Profile





STAFF & CONTRIBUTORS // CONTACT US

Bands: A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z


Site Copyright 2005-2023 Sputnikmusic.com
All Album Reviews Displayed With Permission of Authors | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy